Critics, winemakers and merchants alike are sounding the death knell for garagiste wines.
Jean-Luc Thunevin and Francois Mitjaville founding fathers of the garagiste movement are distancing themselves from the concept which they believe has no long-term potential.
Banker-turned-winemaker Thunevin once epitomised the iconoclastic, fiercely independent, small-scale Bordeaux producer with his micro-cuvee Valandraud, launched in 1991.
The wine, which garnered high praise from Robert Parker, set off a trend which was fiercely criticised for being 'anti-terroir' from the beginning.
Now Thunevin has told La Revue du Vin de France that 'garage wines are made by winemakers who try to compensate for a lack of means and poor terroir by applying modern techniques and efficiencies'.
Mitjaville, of Chateau Tetre Rotebeouf, said, 'Garage wine has no long term potential. I prefer the term petit-cru. Garage wine is not based on any notion of terroir.'
Many critics have always decried the term garagiste coined by then-Revue du Vin de France critic Michel Bettane. Sothebys wine chief Serena Sutcliffe told decanter.com she has always been 'dead against' it, and she stresses the terroir worked by Mitjaville and Thunevin is first class. She refers to the latter as 'a genius'.
But others now question the very concept of low-yield, very ripe, highly-extracted micro-cuvees. Bordeaux-based consultant Stephane Derenoncourt believes the success of wine made in such conditions usually comes down to a triumph of marketing over quality.
'The majority [of such wine] is of no interest: ripeness, concentration and oak are not enough to make a good wine.'
And Decanter consultant editor Steven Spurrier who says he 'predicted the demise of this fad years ago' - is one of many critics who say the wine isn't standing the test of time.
'If you taste a 1995 Valandraud against a Beausejour Becot from the same year, the Valandraud tastes pretty tired,' he told decanter.com.
Merchants, too, confirm the style has been dropping off the fashion radar for a while. Stephen Browett of Farr Vintners said, 'It was very fashionable to say my yield is lower than yours, my Parker points are much higher than yours, my wine is blacker than yours. Now consumers are turning back to famous names and great terroirs.'
Have your say... To post your comment on this story, email us at news@decanter.com, making sure the relevant headline is in the subject field
I produce what maybe considered a "garagiste" wine, here in Mendoza, Argentina.
What the article proves is that critics gauge the new style with elements that this style tries to leave behind. Terroir does not exists, at least it cannot be expalined in technical or chemical words and reasoning. On the other hand, it compares two old wines, pointing that the traditional as the better one. Maybe it is, but who wants to drink old, Bordeaux style wines when you enjoy a "garagiste"-style wine?
The two can survive together; they should aim at different wine lovers.
Ricardo Santos, Mendoza, Argentina
I truly don't understand what people mean when they say that terroir doesn't exist. If terroir is all the physical chararcteristics that affect a vineyard, how can anyone say that the place where grapes are grown won't affect the end product? If terroir didn't exist you could grow Pinot Noir in Bordeaux and still get the same results as you do in Burgundy!
Christian Torok
We produce garagagiste wine here in Cape Town, South Africa.
I am confused by the article claiming that garagiste wine lack terroir..? Surely a garagiste wine can carry the signature of the wines of the area where the grapes are sourced just as good, if not better than wines that are produced en masse in the neigbouring cellar. The one very definite advantage that the garagiste wine will always have over the larger scale production wine, is that the wine gets individual, personal care and attention. Most garagistes can only barely afford the one barrel at-a-time, so the wine is loved into life. The terroir is expressed even better in this way as long as the garagiste winemaker understands the uniqueness of the grapes that he is working with.
Ricardo, perhaps we could swop a bottle or 2 and taste each other's products..?
Chris Kreef, FynVlieg Wine club, Stellenbosch, South Africa
I truly don't understand what people mean when they say that terroir doesn't exist. If terroir is all the physical chararcteristics that affect a vineyard, how can anyone say that the place where grapes are grown won't affect the end product? If terroir didn't exist you could grow Pinot Noir in Bordeaux and still get the same results as you do in Burgundy!
Christian Torok, Miami, FL, USA
Register on decanter.com absolutely free for news alerts delivered direct to your email inbox, and our fortnightly newsletter with advance notice of whats coming up in Decanter magazine, offers, competitions and more.
PLUS registration is a one-stop shop for the Decanter magazine Archive and Decanter Fine Wine Tracker.
I produce what maybe considered a "garagiste" wine, here in Mendoza, Argentina.
