'Pregnant women should avoid all alcohol': UK government May 25, 2007
Maggie Rosen
The UK government has advised women who are pregnant to avoid alcohol altogether - in advice that contradicts its own previous guidance.
Previously government - and most physicians - have advised one to two units per week of wine is acceptable.
The Department of Health admitted the revised position, which also applies to women trying to conceive, was not based on any new medical research.
Indeed, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists continues to maintain that there is no evidence that the previously recommended moderate consumption is detrimental to foetal development.
'My midwife told me that one two units of alcohol – a pint of beer or a small glass of wine – is fine, and I have been following this advice,' said Akiko Mumford, an advertising executive in London who is six months pregnant. 'If I'm out at night and I want to have a drink, I do.'
The Portman Group, a drinks industry-funded association that promotes responsible drinking and a balanced understanding of alcohol-related issues, would not comment on the new recommendation itself.
'Pregnant women should be made aware of this medical advice and the risk of drinking alcohol during pregnancy,' said chief executive David Poley. 'We are having constructive discussions with the government about what more the industry can do to effectively communicate this advice.'
While the effects of binge-drinking are unclear – and heavy consumption during pregnancy is known to cause birth defects – the anti-alcohol and children's charities claim that no amount is safe, and advocate a blanket ban.
'To be honest, I am annoyed that the government – which we are supposed to look to for advice – makes these kinds of announcements with no facts to back them up,' said Mumford.
'It seems like the anti-alcohol lobby is pushing them into it, and I feel they are ill-informing women across the UK. We'll end up with a situation very similar to that of the US, where everyone is incredibly judgmental. Most women are smart enough to ask for advice and follow it. I think the recommendation of one to two units is sensible and I am confident I am doing no harm.'
In a similar move, Alcohol Concern recently advocated that parents who serve alcohol at home to their children under 15 should be prosecuted.
Have your say... To post your comment on this story, email us at news@decanter.com, making sure the relevant headline is in the subject field
This seems to me to be another issue this government cannot leave be. They have to meddle with everything – their motto seems to be “if it's working let's mess it up”. The anti alcohol groups, like puritans everywhere, want to control what we do so that we behave in a way that they approve of. I feel very sorry for pregnant women (and their partners) who must now be totally confused. Let's hope it does not lead to a US style - “Oh my god she's drinking” insanity.
It reminds me of the situation with Cannabis – one minute it's moved a category C status and appears to be moving towards decrimilisation then, hey presto, suddenly there is a massive media explosion saying “cannabis is rotting the brains of our children” and should be reclassified again – what are parents supposed to make of this when dealing with this problem at home?
Then we have Wi-Fi networks – the government is pushing mass expansion of these networks when there is mounting evidence to point that radiation from this source is dangerous and could, indeed, be “rotting our children's brains” - again conflicting and mixed messages from the morons in Westminster (perhaps their Wi-Fi networks have rotted their brains?).
It really is confusing, misleading and pointless – another symptom of New Labour's desire to appear to please all of the people all of the time whilst actually causing chaos, upset and in some cases despair.
Register on decanter.com absolutely free for news alerts delivered direct to your email inbox, and our fortnightly newsletter with advance notice of what’s coming up in Decanter magazine, offers, competitions and more.
PLUS registration is a one-stop shop for the Decanter magazine Archive and Decanter Fine Wine Tracker.
