Bordeaux 2006 futures are priced too high, American importers and distributors say.
Sales are difficult - and the weakness of the dollar against the euro alone does not explain slow sales.
'The Bordelais priced 2006 futures so high to make sales difficult in the US,' Mark Levin, vice president at Southern Wine and Spirits, which operates in 26 states, told decanter.com.
'Traditional Bordeaux customers are turning away from Bordeaux futures as a result.'
In Washington DC, Mark Wessels of importer MacArthur Beverages said sales of Bordeaux were strong but 2006 was 'extraordinarily slow, for the obvious reasons – coming after the greatest vintage ever in 2005, the weak dollar and prices coming out higher than expected.'
In Illinois, Chicago Wine Company representative Simon Lambert called the 2006 futures campaign 'fair.'
'It is not any secret that most people were disappointed with the pricing policies of most of the chateaux,' he added. 'We decided to buy less wine [for the 2006 futures campaign]. In some instances, none, but more because of price than for quality.'
Some warn against a negative trend. 'The quality of the 2007 harvest does not matter,' Levin said. 'If the standard for pricing in Bordeaux is the 2005 vintage, they are going to leave a lot of customers behind in the US.'
For his part, Wessels said he hoped it would not be 'a repeat of 1997 when several retailers ended up selling the wine at cost or below.'
New York may be the one city that bucks the trend. There sales are 'much better than we ever anticipated,' said Michael Aaron of retail store Sherry Lehmann. 'We are selling at a more rapid rate than the 2004 at the same period of time.
American wine drinkers are paying more attention than they ever did before. There is a new generation of Bordeaux drinkers coming into the market.'
Have your say... To post your comment on this story, email us at news@decanter.com, making sure the relevant headline is in the subject field
For the first time in 9 years I will buy zero Bordeaux on futures. In fact, I plan to buy no 2006s (and probably no 2007s) until they show up in the discount bins in 7-8 years, just like the over-priced, over-hyped 1997s. Since I know of no other wine-friends who plan to buy any either, I hope the Bordelaise have a lot of storage space. It could have been a much different scenario if Bordeaux didn't buy into their own hype and give into anti-consumer pricing.
A. Skroback, NYC, USA
Reading the story about Bordeaux 2006 futures just confirms my feelings. Why buy them? The wines have gotten so ridiculously expensive. I refuse to tie my money for bottles which will be available off the shelf or on discount bins later on. No way.
Drew Jenson, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA
Register on decanter.com absolutely free for news alerts delivered direct to your email inbox, and our fortnightly newsletter with advance notice of what’s coming up in Decanter magazine, offers, competitions and more.
PLUS registration is a one-stop shop for the Decanter magazine Archive and Decanter Fine Wine Tracker.
For the first time in 9 years I will buy zero Bordeaux on futures. In fact, I plan to buy no 2006s (and probably no 2007s) until they show up in the discount bins in 7-8 years, just like the over-priced, over-hyped 1997s. Since I know of no other wine-friends who plan to buy any either, I hope the Bordelaise have a lot of storage space. It could have been a much different scenario if Bordeaux didn't buy into their own hype and give into anti-consumer pricing.
