Decanter Magazine - the route to all good wine

Latest issue
Subscribe
Renew online
Buy Decanter:
In the UK
In the US
Find your nearest
UK newsagent

Advertisements
Free Newsletters
Keep up to date with our FREE daily news alerts and monthly newsletters including decantertrade
Shopping Mall

Retailers
UK and Europe
Worldwide
Shopping
Property
Recruitment
Books
Accessories & Gifts
Storage & Refrigeration
Tourism

Learning Route
Free tasting kit
Links
Wine courses
Wine clubs
The basics
Wine terminology - grapes
How do they taste?
Glossary
Wine Investment
Features
2009 Harvest reports
Burgundy 2007
Bordeaux 2008
Book reviews
Am I a great vintage?
Bordeaux En Primeur
Other Features
Events reports
Events slideshows
Decanter contributors
For the facts about alcohol Drinkaware.co.uk
RSS Feed

Latest News

Broadbent and Parker go head to head in London

July 11, 2008
By Lucy Shaw

Decanter columnist Michael Broadbent was pitted against Robert Parker in a head-to-head ratings battle last night at a London tasting of some of Bordeaux's top chateau.

Organised by Roberson of South Kensington, the tasting consisted of wines including 1985 Chateau Lafite Rothschild, 1989 Chateau d'Issan, 1986 Chateau Beychevelle, 1996 Chateau Leoville-Barton and 2000 Chateau Pavie.

The aim was to see whether the audience, who had paid £100 a ticket, aligned themselves more with Broadbent or Parker. The critics' ratings for each of the wines remained undisclosed until the end.

Each of the wines had been praised by one critic and marked down by the other. Tasters were asked to vote for their favourite wines at the end of every flight.

The ten wines were judged in pairs, with Broadbent or Parker gaining a point for each of their favoured wines that received the highest number of audience votes.

Broadbent emerged victorious on the night, beating Parker by three points to two after a final recount.

The Broadbent-favoured 1985 Chateau Lafite Rothschild beat Parker-praised 1986 Chateau L'Eglise Clinet by 36 votes to 7, while 1996 Chateau Leoville-Barton, described by Parker as 'brilliantly made with plenty of muscle and outstanding concentration', triumphed over Broadbent's 4 star 1993 Chateau Pichon-Lalande by 33 votes to 10.

Critics present included the Observer's Tim Atkin, Malcolm Gluck, The Guardian's Victoria Moore and Neal Martin from erobertparker.com.


The event stirred up a heated debate, though it was recognized that the results were of no statistical value. Atkin said, 'It was a fascinating exercise, but I wish we'd done it blind. People give high scores to wines they think they should like. They see the name Lafite and are swayed, whereas I think it showed poorly.'

'I was really impressed with the Pavie (given 100 points by Parker). I thought it was going to be fat, blowsy and over-oaked but it was actually a really smart, well-made wine.'

Martin aligned himself with Parker on the majority of the wines. 'Though I did side with Michael on the Lafite', he said.

Have your say...
To post your comment on this story, email us at news@decanter.com, making sure the relevant headline is in the subject field

For an American Wine Society event we did a similar taste-off. However, we had the audience evaluate each wine and then we presented the word descriptions and asked the members which description best matched what they personally thought of the wine. We then collected the votes for each reviewer for each of the wines. The results were very idiosyncratic in that no one reviewer was consistently better than another. The only conclusion that I can draw from this is that each reviewer has their strengths and weaknesses and occasionally a reviewer can have an off day. Also the wines are reviewed very early on in their life and they can evolve even over the course of a few years. A valid comparison would probably take many wines over several vintages to get a large enough statistical base to be reliable.
Tone Kelly

Register on decanter.com absolutely free for news alerts delivered direct to your email inbox, and our fortnightly newsletter with advance notice of what’s coming up in Decanter magazine, offers, competitions and more.

PLUS registration is a one-stop shop for the Decanter magazine Archive and Decanter Fine Wine Tracker.

Search for similar news stories

Back to index

Advertisements
Shopping directory
Poll
Can you make fine wine over 14%?
To comment on this month's poll email editor@decanter.com

Members Log in

Username
Password
keep me signed in unless I sign out

Register free Forgot password?

Decanter worldwide

Chinese
Hungarian

Sister sites

House to Home
Country Life
Horse & Hound
The Field
Shooting UK
Homes & Gardens
Ideal Home
Yachting and Boating World
All IPC Media sites

Contact Us

Editorial...support...
sales...marketing...
Decanter media pack

Contact us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Sitemap | Trusted Reviews
© Copyright 2007 IPC Media Limited, All rights reserved