Heavy metals in wine could pose potential health problems to regular drinkers, claims a scientific report published today.
The report, which appeared in the online journal Chemistry Central, claims that a daily 250ml glass of red wine could expose wine drinkers to hazardous levels of metal ions linked to Parkinson's disease and cancer.
According to the study, wines from Portugal, Hungary, France and Austria are among those to have dangerous levels of metal ions. Argentinian, Brazilian and Italian wines registered very small levels of the so-called 'heavy metals'.
Using a formula developed in the US to estimate health risks, boffins at Kingston University in London analysed the wines against a Target Health Quotient (THQ). A THQ of one is considered safe. Looking at a range of elements including vanadium, manganese, chromium, zinc, copper, nickel and lead, the researchers found that THQ levels in red wine were around 110.
Professor Declan Naughton, co-author of the report, called for consumers to be made aware of the risks.
'Levels of metal ions should appear on wine labels,' he said, 'along with the introduction of further steps to remove key hazardous metal ions during wine production.'
Naughton, who told decanter.com he still enjoyed drinking red wine, stressed he was calling for a 'regulatory push' – not an end to wine drinking.
He said he could only speculate as to how metal ions get into wine, but that soil types, vineyard sprays and yeasts were the likely culprits. The study added that 'processing and packaging may add to the metal'.
Although it contains some of the highest levels of metal ions, wine is not alone is posing a risk. Apple juice and stout was also found to have a THQ above one.
The Food Standards Agency (FSA) has tried to reassure consumers, saying it has yet to review the findings in full. A spokesperson for the FSA said the scientists' methods were 'not widely used in Europe'.
Have your say... To post your comment on this story, email us at news@decanter.com, making sure the relevant headline is in the subject field
Have any studies been done on Australian wines?
Dean Bolto
I think the phrase “a formula developed in the US to estimate health risks” probably says enough to put this idiocy in context. . .
Brian St. Pierre, London, UK
It's no laughing matter. Three weeks ago I was pouring the last glass from a bottle of Canon-Fronsac when a large anvil fell out of the bottle, crushing my hand and ending my career as a pianist.
Paul J. Kiernan, Dublin, Ireland
Ok ok ok, and again...If I have understood, I have to tell to all my old friend from St-Emilion, Maury, Volnay, Sancerre, etc... STOP!! You risk a bloody Cancer or Parkinson's disease!! They have been approximately 85 years old, they used drinking 3 glasses of wines per day.
It is funny because the loved listening Heavy Metal and specialy the new AC/DC and with their drinker past, they should be charged in ION like a super hero. Tell me seriously, If I am listening AC/DC and drinking for example a delicious Domaine Depeyrre Côtes du Roussillon Villages red wine glass, do I have a big risk?
Eric Ecolan
The very reason why wine is attributed to health is that it contains molecules called polyphenols that bind to heavy metals. Therefore you find a trace of heavy metals in wine. But this is not deleterious. Wine drinking actually deceases the risk of age-related brain disease because these molecules bind up loose metals in the brain that promote aging. The study by the British researchers mischaracterizes wine.
Bill Sardi, USA
Register on decanter.com absolutely free for news alerts delivered direct to your email inbox, and our fortnightly newsletter with advance notice of what’s coming up in Decanter magazine, offers, competitions and more.
PLUS registration is a one-stop shop for the Decanter magazine Archive and Decanter Fine Wine Tracker.
