Pomerol 2010: panel tasting results

1 4.75 5
This tasting naturally invited comparisons with the (also highly regarded) 2009 vintage in Pomerol. 2010 offers some great wines, but for the longer haul, agreed our tasters. See the top 17 wines including 3 Outstandings here...
Pomerol 2010, Château La Truffe
2 of 17

Château La Truffe
Decanter average score:
18.5pts/20 (95/100pts)
Individual judges' scores: Stephen Brook 18.5 James Lawther MW 18.5 Steven Spurrier 18.5
Jean Garde was already owner of Domaine Grand Ormeau in Lalande-de- Pomerol when he established this 2.4-hectare domaine in 2007, naming it after the aromas that are often present when a fine Pomerol is mature. The soils combine clay and gravel, a classic mix among the better growths in the appellation. The vines include 5% each of Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc, the remainder being Merlot. Their average age is 35 years. Garde ages the wine in one- and two-year-old barrels to avoid excessive oakiness and allow the fruit to come through clearly.
Stephen Brook: Sweet, juicy, oaky nose with cherry fruit – has flair and charm. Rich and succulent, with good density of fruit. Not an extracted style, yet it has ample structure and grip, and the acidity gives it drive, elegance and length. Unformed and rugged now but there’s admirable potential here.
James Lawther MW: Serious but with an elegant, fragrant nose with violet notes. Poised and structured; fresh and long. There is power but elegance as well. Firm but refined tannins. Complex. A lovely wine.
Steven Spurrier: Great expression of vineyard fruit on the nose; lifted and more terroir- than varietal-driven. Quite broad on the palate, still firm, needs time for the acidity and tannins to blend together, but a very good future.
Price: £22.95 York Wines
Drink 2015-2035
Alc 14%

Pomerol 2010, Château La Conseillante
Pomerol 2010, Château La Truffe
Pomerol 2010, Clos Vieux Taillefer
Pomerol 2010, Château Beauregard