Expert’s Choice: Old Vine South Africa
A landmark tasting of wines produced from South Africa’s oldest vine stock was both fascinating and revealing. Nancy Gilchrist MW picks her favourites of the day...
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
You are now subscribed
Your newsletter sign-up was successful
In June 2017, South Africa House in Trafalgar Square, London, was the venue for a landmark tasting. The Old Vine Project had come to town, and on offer were some of the most exciting wines yet to emerge from the Cape.
The Old Vine Project (OVP) had its roots in 2002 when leading viticulturist Rosa Kruger began searching out old vineyards – minimum 35 years – because they ‘reflect the earth and the terroir they grow in… Age in vines brings an intensity, a perceived freshness, a texture and a sense of place.’
Nancy Gilchrist MW’s top 18 old-vine wines from South Africa
In 2016 the project received a boost with sponsorship from Johann Rupert of Swiss-based luxury goods company Richemont, while in the same year former Wines of South Africa UK director André Morgenthal and viticulturist Jaco Engelbrecht were appointed as marketing and viticultural advisor respectively. The OVP seeks to raise awareness of the oenological and economic benefits of old vines, both internally in South Africa so that current young vines will be nurtured and preserved, and internationally so that global consumers will be prepared to pay the price necessary to sustain these viticultural links to the cultural past.
Remarkably, South Africa has no fewer than 39 grape varieties in its list of old vineyards. The major variety by far is Chenin Blanc at 52%, followed by Cinsault and Pinotage, both at 5%, Palomino at 4% and Sauvignon Blanc, Semillon, Syrah and Tinta Barocca next in the rankings. These are mostly bush vines and – importantly at a time of significant climate change – most are dry-farmed (unirrigated).
Engelbrecht, who has specialised in the rehabilitation of old vineyards, is researching what it is that has made these specific vines survive: they have much to teach us. By making use of Geographic Information Systems, Englebrecht hopes to establish a more scientific approach to growing healthier old vines.
Currently, it is thought there are about 2,640ha of old vines in South Africa – representing about 1% of total plantings – but many more could be identified before long. Morgenthal estimates that around 80% of these old vines are within the cooperative system, meaning that members are obliged to sell to their cellar or face financial penalties. If the OVP is successful, individual vineyard owners may be able to sell their old-vine harvests directly to willing purchasers for much higher returns. The beneficial impact on some of the less advantaged members of society is clear.
The London OVP tasting was the very first South African old-vines tasting in the UK. Of the 77 wines shown, the majority were white, but almost all were received with genuine admiration, white and red, dry and sweet. The following are some of the highlights.
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
Nancy Gilchrist MW is a freelance wine educator and consultant with a focus on wine and food. She also publishes www.mattersoftaste.co.uk
See Nancy Gilchrist MW’s top 18 old-vine wines from South Africa
You may also like
Getting better with age: Old-vine Chenin Blanc in South Africa10 top South Africa wines worth seeking outCape Town: Top restaurants and wine barsSouth Africa’s 2019 wine harvest is smallest for 14 years
Alheit Vineyards, La Colline Vineyard, Franschhoek, South Africa, 2016

A tautly coiled, waxy white peach-scented, co-fermented field blend of 81-year-old Semillon Blanc with Semillon Gris. A fine-lined and precise wine that will suit long-term...
2016
FranschhoekSouth Africa
Alheit Vineyards
Alheit Vineyards, Magnetic North Mountain Makstok, Citrusdal Mountain, South Africa, 2016

Another hit from Chris and Suzann Alheit. Two adjacent parcels of ungrafted Chenin vines: delicate pear and white blossom yet great persistence.
2016
Citrusdal MountainSouth Africa
Alheit Vineyards
The Sadie Family, Die Ouwingerdreeks ’T Voetpad, Swartland, South Africa, 2016

Remarkable blend of Semillons Blanc and Gris, Chenin Blanc, Palomino and Muscat, vines as old as 129 years.
2016
SwartlandSouth Africa
The Sadie Family
Thorne & Daughters, Paper Kite Old Vines Semillon, Franschhoek, South Africa, 2016

Porcelain elegance. White pepper and fresh peach, very long, balanced, persistent flavour. Still a lot to unfurl.
2016
FranschhoekSouth Africa
Thorne & Daughters
Alheit Vineyards, Radio Lazarus, Bottelary, Stellenbosch, South Africa, 2016

Bush-vine Chenin Blanc from hilltop vineyards planted in 1970 and 1978. Ripe pear, buttery apple compote notes. Seriously delicious; will evolve beautifully.
2016
StellenboschSouth Africa
Alheit VineyardsBottelary
Gabriëlskloof, Elodie, Bot River, Walker Bay, South Africa, 2015

Peter-Allan Finlayson has recently taken over the winemaking here, and he has produced an elegant, finely crafted Chenin from 38-year old vines.
2015
Walker BaySouth Africa
GabriëlskloofBot River
AA Badenhorst, The Golden Slopes Chenin Blanc, Swartland, South Africa, 2016

Conjures up mouthwatering, buttery pastry and ripe apples. Rich and seriously delicious, has immense length.
2016
SwartlandSouth Africa
AA Badenhorst
Mullineux, Old Vines White, Swartland, South Africa, 2014

An inspired Chenin Blanc-based blend. Subtle quince, apple and orange rind with a luscious, supple palate.
2014
SwartlandSouth Africa
Mullineux
Reyneke, Biodynamic Chenin Blanc, Polkadraai Hills, Stellenbosch, South Africa, 2015

Ripe, healthy Comice pears, a vibrant, moreish wine from one of SA’s standout biodynamic producers.
2015
StellenboschSouth Africa
ReynekePolkadraai Hills
Beaumont, Hope Marguerite, Bot River, Walker Bay, South Africa, 2016

A consistently stunning Chenin Blanc sourced from vines planted in 1974 and 1978 and barrel-fermented. I sampled this alongside the 2014, 2011, 2009 and 2006:...
2016
Bot RiverSouth Africa
Beaumont
David & Nadia, Chenin Blanc, Swartland, South Africa, 2016

A real beauty! Aromas of pears and stewed apple. Concentrated flavours enhanced by light oak give a really satisfying weight and length.
2016
SwartlandSouth Africa
David & Nadia
Cape of Good Hope, Antonij Rupert Wyne, Laing Semillon, Citrusdal Mountain, South Africa, 2015

59-year-old Semillon vines with 11% Sauvignon Blanc. Stylish, fine-boned. Waxy lemon and lime with white blossom notes. Creamy and well balanced.
2015
Citrusdal MountainSouth Africa
Cape of Good Hope
Boekenhoutskloof, Semillon, Franschhoek, South Africa, 2014

With a smidge of Sauvignon Blanc, this is predominantly Semillon from seriously old vines, some 112 years old. Subtle use of oak, mouthfilling texture.
2014
FranschhoekSouth Africa
Boekenhoutskloof
AA Badenhorst, Raaigras, Swartland, South Africa, 2016

Made from purportedly the oldest (64 years) Grenache vines in South Africa. Ethereal and complex aromas of summer, old books and a touch of leather....
2016
SwartlandSouth Africa
AA Badenhorst
The Sadie Family, Die Ouwingerdreeks Treinspoor, Swartland, South Africa, 2016

Unusual, wild-at-heart wine from 42-year-old bush-vine Tinta Barocca. Unique and ‘of its place’.
2016
SwartlandSouth Africa
The Sadie Family
Darling Cellars, Old Bush Vines Cinsaut, Darling, South Africa, 2015

Dark fruit, racy acidity and fine tannins just beginning to come together, with intriguing fennel/liquorice on the finish. An attractive partner to food.
2015
DarlingSouth Africa
Darling Cellars
Boutinot, Percheron Old Vine Cinsault, Western Cape, South Africa, 2016

Made from 100% Cinsault from 45-year-old vines, this is a refreshing, light-bodied wine crammed with easy-going damson, plum and raspberry flavours.
2016
Western CapeSouth Africa
Boutinot
Klawer Wine Cellars, Villa Esposto Straw Wine, Olifants River, South Africa, 2016

From 47-year-old Muscat d’Alexandrie vines, grapes dried for two weeks on straw mats. Rich peach, sultana tea cake, lemon zest. Long and memorable.
2016
Olifants RiverSouth Africa
Klawer Wine Cellars

After a time of great vinous curiosity at Cambridge University, Nancy Gilchrist MW spent a glorious year driving a double-decker bus as a tour guide in Washington DC. Then the siren-call of wine drew her to run the Carlton Wine Bar near the White House and later to write a wine column for The Boston Globe. Upon returning to her native UK, she ran Grants of St James’s School of Wine, eventually leaving to work independently, passing the Master of Wine exams in 1995. Clients have included IBM, Coca Cola, Chanel, Allen & Overy, and Cordon Bleu but she teaches regularly at Leiths School of Food & Wine where she devised the module on the interaction of wine & food. Nancy took over running the Christie’s Wine Course from Steven Spurrier and Michael Broadbent MW and resurrected it in 2018 as Academie du Vin. She was Champagne Ambassador UK for 2013 and is now consultant to the Oxford Wine Company. She also represents the Consorzio Vini Alto Adige and acts as UK ambassador for I & P – a boutique olive oil producer in Lazio, Italy. Nancy Gilchrist MW was a judge at the 2019 Decanter World Wine Awards (DWWA), she first judged the competition in 2014.