30 years on | Decanter

The results of the Paris tasting re-run....

FLIGHT 1 – ORIGINAL REDS

Swipe to scroll horizontally

WINE
No.	Name	Total UK Points	RANK UK	Total US Points	RANK US	Total Combined Points	RANK TOTAL
1	Freemark Abbey 1969	75	10	64	9	139	10
2	Clos du Val 1972	46	4	46	5	92	5
3	Heitz Martha’s Vineyard 1970	49	7	37	3	86	3
4	Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars 1973	43	3	36	2	79	2
5	Château Montrose 1970	46	4	60	7	106	7
6	Ridge Monte Bello 1971	29	1	32	1	61	1
7	Château Léoville-Las-Cases 1971	67	9	65	10	132	9
8	Château Mouton-Rothschild 1970	40	2	53	6	93	6
9	Château Haut-Brion 1970	53	8	63	8	116	8
10	Mayacamas 1971	47	6	39	4	86	3

FLIGHT 2 – WHITE BURGUNDIES

Swipe to scroll horizontally

No.	Name	Total 9 Panel UK	9 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 31 Panel UK	31 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 40 Panel UK	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – UK
1	Puligny-Montrachet 2002 Domaine Leflaive	19	1	102	2	121	1
2	Meursault 1er Cru 2002 Domaine Roulot	36	4	122	6	158	6
3	Beaune 2002 Domaine Drouhin	28	3	105	3	133	2
4	Bâtard-Montrachet 2002 Louis Latour	37	5	106	4	143	4
5	Chassagne-Montrachet 2002 Louis Jadot	24	2	115	5	139	3
6	Corton-Charlemagne 2003 Bonneau du Martray	45	6	101	1	146	5
Row 7 - Cell 0
Row 8 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 9 Panel US	9 PANEL RANK – US	Total 31 Panel US	31 PANEL RANK – US	Total 40 Panel US	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – US
1	Puligny-Montrachet 2002 Domaine Leflaive	16	1	91	1	107	1
2	Meursault 1er Cru 2002 Domaine Roulot	30	3	142	6	172	6
3	Beaune 2002 Domaine Drouhin	26	2	104	4	130	3
4	Bâtard-Montrachet 2002 Louis Latour	37	5	92	2	129	2
5	Chassagne-Montrachet 2002 Louis Jadot	35	4	123	5	158	5
6	Corton-Charlemagne 2003 Bonneau du Martray	45	6	99	3	144	4
Row 16 - Cell 0
Row 17 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 18 Panel Combined	18 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 31 Panel UK & US	62 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 40 Panel UK & US	COMBINED 80 PANEL RANK – TOTAL
1	Puligny-Montrachet 2002 Domaine Leflaive	35	1	193	1	228	1
2	Meursault 1er Cru 2002 Domaine Roulot	66	4	264	6	330	6
3	Beaune 2002 Domaine Drouhin	54	2	209	4	263	2
4	Bâtard-Montrachet 2002 Louis Latour	74	5	198	2	272	3
5	Chassagne-Montrachet 2002 Louis Jadot	59	3	238	5	297	5
6	Corton-Charlemagne 2003 Bonneau du Martray	90	6	200	3	290	4

FLIGHT 3 – CALIFORNIAN CHARDONNAYS

Swipe to scroll horizontally

No.	Name	Total 9 Panel UK	9 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 31 Panel UK	31 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 40 Panel UK	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – UK
1	Talley 2002 Rosemary’s Vineyard	27	3	94	1	121	1
2	Patz & Hall 2004 Hyde Vineyard	26	2	107	3	133	3
3	Ramey 2002 Hyde Vineyard	22	1	101	2	123	2
4	Mount Eden Vineyard 2002	47	6	121	6	168	6
5	Château Montelena 2003	32	4	111	4	143	4
6	Peter Michael 2003 Point Rouge	35	5	117	5	152	5
Row 7 - Cell 0
Row 8 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 9 Panel US	9 PANEL RANK – US	Total 31 Panel US	31 PANEL RANK – US	Total 40 Panel US	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – US
1	Talley 2002 Rosemary’s Vineyard	15	1	103	3	118	1
2	Patz & Hall 2004 Hyde Vineyard	30	2	97	2	127	3
3	Ramey 2002 Hyde Vineyard	32	3	90	1	122	2
4	Mount Eden Vineyard 2002	39	6	126	5	165	5
5	Château Montelena 2003	37	5	103	3	140	4
6	Peter Michael 2003 Point Rouge	36	4	132	6	168	6
Row 16 - Cell 0
Row 17 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 18 Panel Combined	18 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 31 Panel UK & US	62 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 40 Panel UK & US	COMBINED 80 PANEL RANK – TOTAL
1	Talley 2002 Rosemary’s Vineyard	42	1	197	2	239	1
2	Patz & Hall 2004 Hyde Vineyard	56	3	204	3	260	3
3	Ramey 2002 Hyde Vineyard	54	2	191	1	245	2
4	Mount Eden Vineyard 2002	87	6	247	5	334	6
5	Château Montelena 2003	70	4	214	4	284	4
6	Peter Michael 2003 Point Rouge	72	5	249	6	321	5

FLIGHT 4 – RED BORDEAUX

Swipe to scroll horizontally

No.	Name	Total 9 Panel UK	9 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 31 Panel UK	31 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 40 Panel UK	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – UK
1	Château Montrose 2000	27	2	114	3	141	3
2	Château Latour 2000	29	3	114	3	143	4
3	Chateau Haut-Brion 2000	40	6	98	2	138	2
4	Château Léoville-Las-Cases 2001	35	4	128	6	163	6
5	Château Margaux 2000	21	1	87	1	108	1
6	Château Rauzan-Ségla 2000	37	5	110	3	147	5
Row 7 - Cell 0
Row 8 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 9 Panel US	9 PANEL RANK – US	Total 31 Panel US	31 PANEL RANK – US	Total 40 Panel US	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – US
1	Château Montrose 2000	38	5	123	5	161	6
2	Château Latour 2000	38	5	101	2	139	3
3	Chateau Haut-Brion 2000	29	3	115	4	144	4
4	Château Léoville-Las-Cases 2001	33	4	125	6	158	5
5	Château Margaux 2000	25	1	81	1	106	1
6	Château Rauzan-Ségla 2000	26	2	106	3	132	2
Row 16 - Cell 0
Row 17 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 18 Panel Combined	18 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 31 Panel UK & US	62 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 40 Panel UK & US	COMBINED 80 PANEL RANK – TOTAL
1	Château Montrose 2000	65	3	237	5	302	5
2	Château Latour 2000	67	4	215	3	282	2
3	Chateau Haut-Brion 2000	69	6	213	2	282	2
4	Château Léoville-Las-Cases 2001	68	5	253	6	321	6
5	Château Margaux 2000	46	1	168	1	214	1
6	Château Rauzan-Ségla 2000	63	2	220	4	283	4

FLIGHT 5 – CALIFORNIAN CABERNETS

Swipe to scroll horizontally

No.	Name	Total 9 Panel UK	9 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 31 Panel UK	31 PANEL RANK – UK	Total 40 Panel UK	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – UK
1	Clos du Val 2000 Reserve	33	3	121	6	154	6
2	Shafer Hillside Select 2001	42	6	93	1	135	2
3	Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars Cask 23	21	1	100	2	121	1
4	Joseph Phelps Insignia 2002	33	3	109	3	142	4
5	Ridge Monte Bello 2000	24	2	112	4	136	3
6	Staglin 2001 Rutherford	36	5	116	5	152	5
Row 7 - Cell 0
Row 8 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 9 Panel US	9 PANEL RANK – US	Total 31 Panel US	31 PANEL RANK – US	Total 40 Panel US	COMBINED 40 PANEL RANK – US
1	Clos du Val 2000 Reserve	50	6	132	6	182	6
2	Shafer Hillside Select 2001	25	1	82	1	107	1
3	Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars Cask 23	29	4	126	5	155	5
4	Joseph Phelps Insignia 2002	34	5	110	4	144	4
5	Ridge Monte Bello 2000	25	1	105	3	130	3
6	Staglin 2001 Rutherford	26	3	96	2	122	2
Row 16 - Cell 0
Row 17 - Cell 0
No.	Name	Total 18 Panel Combined	18 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 31 Panel UK & US	62 PANEL RANK – TOTAL	Total 40 Panel UK & US	COMBINED 80 PANEL RANK – TOTAL
1	Clos du Val 2000 Reserve	83	6	253	6	336	6
2	Shafer Hillside Select 2001	67	4	175	1	242	1
3	Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars Cask 23	50	2	226	5	276	4
4	Joseph Phelps Insignia 2002	67	4	219	4	286	5
5	Ridge Monte Bello 2000	49	1	217	3	266	2
6	Staglin 2001 Rutherford	62	3	212	2	274	3

Written by

Explore More

Content written and compiled by the Decanter Team