Wine writer Martin Isark is suing Majestic Wine over the alleged misuse of a tasting note.

Isark, the author of The Supermarket Own Brand Guide, claims the note was used on the wrong vintage and without his permission.

In 2005, he sued Concha y Toro for using one of his tasting notes on the wrong vintages and without permission.

This case, as well as a case involving Direct Wines Ltd, was settled out of court.

It is believed both settlements, including legal costs, ran into six figures.

On his website, Isark writes, ‘There are misconceptions about the use of journalists’ tasting notes.

‘It is often assumed that, once a tasting comment appears “in the public domain”, then it is available to anyone to use. That is not so.’

Majestic Wine did not comment.

WATCH our brilliant new How to taste wine video with Steven Spurrier

Follow us on Twitter

Written by Jim Budd

Explore More
Jim Budd
Decanter Magazine, Wine Writer & Photographer

Jim Budd moved from education to wine in 1988 and has written for Decanter since 1989. He is the former editor (1991-2015) of Circle Update, the newsletter of the Circle of Wine Writers.  He writes the award-winning www.jimsloire.blogspot.com and is one of the five members of the Les 5 du Vin blog. Budd exposes the dangers of drinks investment on his award-winning www.investdrinks.org website, and complementary www.investdrinks-blog.blogspot.com blog. He also contributes to Hugh Johnson’s Pocket Wine Book, Wine Behind the Label and the Academie du Vin. Budd is a keen photographer – especially in the Loire.