Decanter Star buys 2015: Top 10 wines
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
You are now subscribed
Your newsletter sign-up was successful
See below the 10 top wines of 2015 chosen by our panel of three experts for the Decanter 50 star buys series.
Here are the 10 top wines of 2015 based on those that shone best in a blind tasting with a panel of experts for the Decanter star buys 2015 series – first published in the January issue of Decanter magazine.
The tasters were: Peter Richards MW, Sarah Jane Evans MW, Xavier Rousset MS.
All the wines originally scored at least 95 points (rating: ‘outstanding’) in a Decanter tasting in 2015.
See the wines below
There is a strong showing for Australian wine in the top 10 this year, lending more evidence to those who believe Australia is re-inventing itself as a fine wine force with a broader range of wines.
Two Australian Riesling wines have made the top 10, including Pikes, The Merle 2014, from Polish Hill River in Clare Valley, and Pewsey Vale’s The Contours Museum Reserve Riesling 2009 from Eden Valley.
A Pinot Noir from Adelaide Hills, the Pike & Joyce Lenswood 2012, also made the list. The wines are an example of how Australian winemaking has broadened.
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
More classic Australian Shiraz and Chardonnay styles are also represented below, although the expert panel praised their refinement and focus on well-balanced oak integration.
‘Australian Chardonnay has often been criticised as too extracted and over-oaked with high alcohol,’ said Xavier Rousset MS. ‘Producers have reacted to that and it’s paying off.’
Chile is the other New World wine country represented in the top 10, with Viu Manent’s Gran Reserva Chardonnay 2013 from Casablanca.
Representing the so-called ‘Old World’ is San Polo’s Brunello di Montalcino 2010 – one of the greatest vintages in recent memory. Priorat in Spain and a Douro white wine also have a space in the top 10 thanks to producers Costers del Priorat and Wine & Soul.
10 top wines of 2015: Decanter star buys
*Please note: Where a score is given, it is that awarded after the original Decanter tasting.
Vasse Felix, Heytesbury Chardonnay, Margaret River, Western Australia, Australia, 2013

0
Wonderfully complex aromas of fresh dough, roasted nuts and butter. Ripe fruit palate with a rich lemon curd note, along with well integrated oak and balanced sweetness and acidity. Racy and elegant, a stunning and refined modern Chardonnay. Vasse Felix was founded by pioneer Dr Thomas Cullity in 1967 and is now owned by Paul Holmes à Court. It is situated in Margaret River, Australia. It is the founding wine estate of Margaret River. Vasse Felix sits in the Wilyabrup sub-region of Margaret River, with vineyards also located to the north of the region in Carbunup, and to the south, in Karridale, benefit from a micro-climate and natural irrigation. The area has about three main types of soil, a clay based soil, a gravel based type of soil but also a sandy soil. Together, these conditions are ideal for growing Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay.
2013
Margaret RiverAustralia
Vasse Felix
Clonakilla, Shiraz-Viognier Murrumbateman, Canberra District, New South Wales, Australia, 2013

Superb pepper, red fruits and violet aromas. Ultra-fine texture, smooth and gentle tannins and a seamless finish. Remarkably complex for such a young Shiraz. A...
2013
Canberra DistrictAustralia
Clonakilla
Costers del Priorat, Clos Cypres, Priorat, Catalonia, Spain, 2013

95
Winemaker José Mas Barberà joined Costers del Priorat (founded 2002) in 2007. He was drawn to Priorat as a region where he could express the soil in the wine. Clos Cypres, 100% Cariñena from a vineyard in Bellmunt planted in 1939, is fermented in 300-litre amphorae and 500-litre old oak, before ageing in barrique. Mas is searching for freshness ‘I believe in acidity, so I am the first to pick in my village’; and for subtlety ‘I ferment with stems, but I handle the wine like an infusion’. Look out for Clos Cypres Cariñena from its vineyard in Torroja, coming next year. Pedro Ballesteros Torres MW: Delicate in nose, peculiar, with garrigue tones and floral hints. Balanced and open palate. Long, suave finish. Sarah Jane Evans MW: Glorious blueberry aroma with a wild Cariñena typicity. Finishes with fine grip of tannin; very balanced with a dark, savoury undertone. Pierre Mansour: Deep bright colour, clean, pure nose, wonderful cherry notes with a wild herby aroma, savoury too; youthful. It has a tangy palate, intense cherry fruit, well-controlled and totally individual.
2013
CataloniaSpain
Costers del PrioratPriorat
Pewsey Vale, Museum Reserve The Contours Riesling, Eden Valley, South Australia, Australia, 2009

95
<p>The Hill-Smith family’s Pewsey Vale vineyard is an extensive and iconic Eden Valley Riesling site. Its finest fruits, from the oldest vines on its coolest slope, are reserved for late release as The Contours. Chief winemaker Louisa Rose has worked at Yalumba since 1992 and has a soft spot for this site and its wines, taking personal responsibility for their production. She plays with both wild and cultured yeasts, but stresses that this wine is really all about the vineyard, where her recent initiatives focus on biodynamics, revegetation for biodiversity and installation of insectariums.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Sarah Ahmed </strong></em><br /> Lemon curd, lime cordial, lime-shred marmalade, minerality, and a good underlying acidity/saltiness on the palate. Tight, toasty finish with still a lot to give. A very lime marmalade finish.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Justin Knock MW </strong></em><br /> Yum! Creamy, warm and complex with lemon zest lift. Rich and luscious in an atypical Eden Valley style.</p> <p> </p> <p><strong><em>Anthony Rose </em></strong><br /> Classic and rich, with toast, lemon curd and intense Riesling-scented fruit. There’s lovely ripe farm butter and peach on the palate, infused with that enticingly evolved toastiness and light touch of honey that makes bottle-aged Riesling so engaging.</p>
2009
South AustraliaAustralia
Pewsey ValeEden Valley
Pikes, The Merle, Polish Hill River, Clare Valley, Australia, 2014

95
<p>Brothers Neil and Andrew Pike celebrated their 30th vintage at Pikes in the Polish Hill River district of the Clare Valley in 2014. The Merle is their top Riesling, the expression of slate soils tapped by mature vines from two blocks in the family vineyard. The brothers’ attention to detail begins in the vines, with an eco-friendly approach that comes close to organic, including mulching and mid-row cover cropping. Minimalist, modern, temperaturecontrolled winemaking preserves delicacy and vineyard definition.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Sarah Ahmed </strong></em><br /> Lifted lychee nose, sweet heady musk characters, a saline note and a firm, tight, mineral palate.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Justin Knock MW </strong></em><br /> Pristine and extremely aromatic – almost soaring out of the glass. Really classy and fine palate, showing balanced, long flavours of lemon and lime, and a softness to the acidity.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Anthony Rose </strong></em><br /> Lovely, spring-blossom aromatics. Taut and crisp mid-palate fruit that is concentrated and still elemental, but already showing promising citrus fruit quality with a mineral, stony, dry finish. Lots of potential.</p> <p> </p> <p> </p>
2014
Polish Hill RiverAustralia
Pikes
Viu Manent, Gran Reserva, Casablanca Valley, Chile, 2013

95
<p>For its red wines, Viu Manent obtains its fruit from the central area of the Colchagua Valley, where the high temperatures give early maturity and a gentle softness to their wines. For their whites, however, they prefer to buy grapes from closer to the coast, where cold sea breezes enable higher acidity and freshness. This Chardonnay is from Casablanca, 100km north of Colchagua on the coast of the Central Valley, and the marine influence is felt in the wine’s bright acidity, surrounded by ripe white fruit flavours. It’s a voluptuous, round and unctously ripe Chardonnay that still shows an elegant side.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Patricio Tapia </strong></em><br /> This is round and sexy, with luminous acidity to balance beautifully with the with super-ripe fruit.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Dirceu Vianna Jr MW </strong></em><br /> Classy and seductive with profound mineral and flinty edges combining with notes of vibrant and citrus fruits as well as fresh dough. Pleasant texture and savoury flavours, with a mouthwatering finish. Elegant and delicate Chardonnay.</p>
2013
Casablanca ValleyChile
Viu Manent
San Polo, Brunello di Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy, 2010

<p>A combination of the old and the new (fermentation in cement vats but ageing is 24 months in 700-litre tonneaux of new French oak) and...
2010
TuscanyItaly
San PoloBrunello di Montalcino
Xanadu, Reserve Chardonnay, Margaret River, Western Australia, Australia, 2012

0
Fresh green fruit, herbs and hint of wood smoke on the nose. This follows on to honey, beeswax and very pleasant nutty flavours with greengage and lime to compliment. Focused, long and refreshing with a creamy texture.
2012
Western AustraliaAustralia
XanaduMargaret River
Pike & Joyce, Pinot Noir, Adelaide Hills, South Australia, Australia, 2012

95
<p>Established in the ultra-cool, high-elevation village of Lenswood, the Pike & Joyce project is a joint venture between two families of differing origins and experience. The Pike family has a pedigree of high-quality wine production in the Clare Valley and the Joyce family are fifth generation horticulturalists that joined together by marriage and teamed up to establish this 25-hectare estate in 1998. Pinot Noir and Chardonnay have demonstrated they are ideally suited to the terroir here, boosted to a new pinnacle by the outstanding 2012 vintage.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Roger Jones</strong></em><br /> Sweet and delicate palate with great balance between controlled fruit and silky smooth oak. Hints of Asian spices; this would be great with Peking duck as you get lovely Chinese plum jam nuances from this. Complete.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Justin Knock</strong></em><br /> Showstopping whole-bunch aromatics. Autumnal wood smoke, Lapsang Souchong tea, lavender and beautiful yet indefinable red fruits. Really sublime, classy and complex; almost otherworldly.</p> <p> </p> <p><em><strong>Anthony Rose</strong></em><br /> Fine strawberry aromatic quality with lovely spicy oak. There is a seductively juicy mulberry fruit richness, incisive acidity and firm tannins with a firm dry, savoury feel to the finish.</p>
2012
Adelaide HillsAustralia
Pike & Joyce
Chris Mercer is a Bristol-based freelance editor and journalist who spent nearly four years as digital editor of Decanter.com, having previously been Decanter’s news editor across online and print.
He has written about, and reported on, the wine and food sectors for more than 10 years for both consumer and trade media.
Chris first became interested in the wine world while living in Languedoc-Roussillon after completing a journalism Masters in the UK. These days, his love of wine commonly tests his budgeting skills.
Beyond wine, Chris also has an MSc in food policy and has a particular interest in sustainability issues. He has also been a food judge at the UK’s Great Taste Awards.
