Ribera del Duero: Panel tasting results
With its full-bodied, sometimes formidable reds, stylistic shifts are clearly working wonders for Ribera del Duero, with a high proportion of Outstandings and 90-plus point wines among a relatively small field.
Beth Willard, David Williams and Diana Rollan tasted 59 wines, with 6 Outstanding and 20 Highly recommended.
Ribera del Duero: Panel tasting scores
Exceptional 0
Outstanding 6
Highly recommended 20
Recommended 32
Commended 1
Fair 0
Poor 0
Entry criteria: producers and UK agents were invited to submit their current-release, 100% Tempranillo (Tinta del País/Tinto Fino) premium red wines retailing at £15 and above in the UK
It was one of those days that ended with blackened teeth, beaten-up gums and tongues tied up with tannin. Welcome to Ribera del Duero! But rarely had any of us undertaken a panel tasting of such exceptionally high quality and consistency. The wines were representative of an appellation which now sits with ease alongside the other great winemaking regions of the world.
Scroll down to see tasting notes and scores from the Ribera del Duero panel tasting
If you haven’t had a proper look at Ribera del Duero recently, now is the time to revisit this wonderful region of northern Spain. David Williams was both pleased and surprised by the overall freshness and balance of the wines: ‘Things have changed in the past five years.’
Stylistically there has been an important shift in the region to wines which better represent the vineyards, with less extraction and acidity, reflecting the elevation of Ribera [720m-1,100m, according to the Ribera consejo regulador]. This can be seen in the six Outstanding wines selected here. As Diana Rollan went on to explain: ‘The younger generation is producing fresher wines.’
Great typicity, identity and character were on show in this tasting. The wines were bold with intense fruit, high but balanced acid, and evident but well-managed tannin. Many of the wines are born from very old vines – note Dominio de Atauta’s pre-phylloxera vineyards in Soria, at the eastern end of the region – while others are combining concrete vats and larger oak barrels to integrate oak in a more elegant manner. However, there is no denying that this is a region of power and intensity.
Rollan felt that ‘these are great wines, but challenging and not always approachable’. For those new to the region, it takes some time and knowledge to become comfortable with the style and premium prices. Williams lamented ‘it can be an expensive mistake’. Hopefully this selection helps to point out some key names to follow.
Among the top wines in the tasting are some names that have already made their mark in Spain but are not yet well known in this market. Marta Maté is a rising star in Ribera del Duero, a dynamic winery that is worth wider appreciation. And among the highest scorers is Interpretación, made by former Vega Sicilia winemaker Xavier Ausàs, who now has his own project focusing on some of the best parcels across the region.
See all the wines from the Ribera del Duero panel tasting
The panel wasn’t too bothered by the high alcohol of the region, here largely in the range of 14.5%-15.5% – it is Ribera after all! But we recommend sticking mostly with the wines around 14%-14.5%. We struggled with some above this level – but maybe we’re not as capable of coping with it as we once were in our younger and more adventurous days.
While the ageing capacity of some of these wines is truly exceptional and provides a great opportunity for collectors, we loved the vibrancy and immediacy of some of the younger vintages. 2021 is a particularly excellent year whose quality is already clear and would be a great starting point for those looking to revisit the impressively expressive wines of one of the world’s great fine wine regions.
Ribera del Duero panel tasting scores
Wines were tasted blind
The judges
Beth Willard is involved in sourcing wines for both the on- and off-trade in the UK, with a particular focus on Eastern Europe and Spain. Formerly buying manager at Direct Wines, she is a member of Spain’s Gran Orden de Caballeros del Vino, and from 2024 is our new fifth DWWA Co-Chair.
David Williams is wine correspondent for The Observer, a regular contributor to Decanter on all things Spanish, and a widely published wine writer, author and competition judge.
Diana Rollan is group head of beverage for D&D London restaurants group. A DWWA judge for Spain, she formerly managed training and wine buying at Hakkasan Group as its UK head of wine.
Related articles
Emilio Moro, Malleolus, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
The Tinto Fino selected for this is from some of the estate’s oldest vines grown at altitude, about 800m, on particularly poor and stony soils....
2020
Emilio MoroRibera del Duero
Aalto, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2021
Aalto was established in 1999 by Mariano Garcia, winemaker for 30 years at Vega Sicilia. His philosophy was minimal intervention and maximum expression of the...
2021
AaltoRibera del Duero
Dominio de Atauta, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Classic Ribera from a producer in one of the region’s wildest and most rugged areas, the valley of Atauta. The bodega works with pre-phylloxera vines,...
2020
Dominio de AtautaRibera del Duero
Entrecanales Domecq & Hijos, Viña Mayor Secreto, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019
Viña Mayor, on Ribera del Duero’s ‘Golden Mile’, is part of the commercial group which includes the historic Rioja bodega Cosme Palacios. With a focus...
2019
Entrecanales Domecq & HijosRibera del Duero
Marta Maté, Marta Maté, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2021
A wonderful expression of Marta Maté’s 100-year-old vines in Tubilla del Lago, the northernmost town of Ribera del Duero, as well as vineyards in Gumiel...
2021
Marta MatéRibera del Duero
Resalte, Vendimia Seleccionada, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2021
This Tempranillo comes from vines grown at above 1,000m, specially selected for this cuvée. With vineyards around the towns of Manzanillo, Torre de Peñafiel and...
2021
ResalteRibera del Duero
Valduero, Una Cepa, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2018
Aromatic with notes of blackcurrant, violets, tobacco leaf and orange peel. Gently maturing but still vibrant and fresh. Firm, savoury and sweet with integrated tannin...
2018
ValdueroRibera del Duero
Abadia de Acón, Acón Roble, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Perfumed and vibrant notes of red berries, raspberry, cedar wood and dried herbs. Restrained, elegant with fruity, silky tannins and a touch of oak. Vibrant...
2020
Abadia de AcónRibera del Duero
Ausàs Bodegas y Viñedos, Interpretación, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
The child of an irregular vintage, with both cold and hot spells, this has an elegant, mineral tannic framework that lends it verticality and poise...
2020
Ausàs Bodegas y ViñedosRibera del Duero
Portia, Prima La Encina, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Blackcurrant, blueberries, tobacco leaf, cocoa, mocha and cola nut. Mineral and stony with grippy, ripe tannins and refreshing acidity. An intense wine that offers immediate...
2020
PortiaRibera del Duero
Bodegas Montebaco, Montebaco de Finca, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Intense aromas of roasted coffee, vanilla and a touch of cedar wood and cigar. Ripe blackberry and a hint of spice with layers of jammy...
2020
Bodegas MontebacoRibera del Duero
Finca Villacreces, Nebro, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019
Fragrant red and black fruit with notes of blueberry compote, cherry and liquorice. Concentrated fruit, fresh and vibrant acidity. The graphite quality from the oak...
2019
Finca VillacrecesRibera del Duero
Bodegas Balbás, Crianza, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Violets, blackberry, kirsch, cocoa, vanilla and graphite. Weighty and mouthfilling. A brown sugar-like texture, yet dry and compelling, with dark and fleshy fruit. Crunchy, vibrant...
2020
Bodegas BalbásRibera del Duero
Bodegas Cepa 21, Hito, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2021
Elegant with perfumed violets and blueberries, graphite and a touch of vanilla. A hint of strawberry and mulberry; rendered tannins. Balanced with a slightly meaty...
2021
Bodegas Cepa 21Ribera del Duero
Santa Eulalia, Riberal Reserva, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2016
Attractive, elegant and perfumed on the nose. Dark berries, chocolate, cedar, white and black pepper. Juicy, plush and rich with ripe, polished and chalky tannins....
2016
Santa EulaliaRibera del Duero
Bodegas Felix Callejo, Suelos de Caliza, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2018
Plum, raspberry, and blueberry fruit with hints of cedar wood and baking spices. Textured and well-balanced with silky, ripe tannins and a savoury oak character....
2018
Bodegas Felix CallejoRibera del Duero
Conde de San Cristóbal, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2021
Hedgerow berry fruit with blood orange citrus, chocolate, coffee bean and floral notes. Intense with a bittersweet character. Meaty with rounded, silky and polished tannins....
2021
Conde de San CristóbalRibera del Duero
Viñas del Jaro, Jaros, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Dark cherry, raspberry, liquorice, graphite and leather. Bright with a steely backbone, fresh acidity and delicious chocolate notes. A burst of red-cherry acidity and chewy...
2020
Viñas del JaroRibera del Duero
Bodegas La Horra, Corimbo I, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2016
Bramble fruit, liquorice and sweet spice. Creamy, sumptuous fruit, like blackberry and mulberry infused with cinnamon. Mature, balanced tannins with youthful freshness and lively acidity....
2016
Bodegas La HorraRibera del Duero
Dominio Lubiano, Limited Edition, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Opulent and jammy with notes of blueberries, plum, cassis, liquorice and mocha. Well-balanced with a tart, blood orange pithiness. Ripe, round and lifted with delicate...
2020
Dominio LubianoRibera del Duero
Casa Rojo, Tinta Fina, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Earthy, underbrush aromas with hints of fig, raspberry compote, cherry and herbal overtones. Bursting with red plum, spice and a mouthwatering layer of sour fruit....
2020
Casa RojoRibera del Duero
Dominio Fournier, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020
Classically jammy with dark fruit with notes of red berries, herbs, wildflowers and a touch of vanilla. Laced with savoury, grippy tannins, refreshing acidity and...
2020
Dominio FournierRibera del Duero
Figuero, Viñas Viejas, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019
Refined and red-fruited nose with notes of leather, orange peel, rosemary and cocoa. Showing age development, with delicate cherry and mulberry fruit. Fine-grained tannins and...
2019
FigueroRibera del Duero
Tresmano, Proventus, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019
Intense and perfumed, with notes of red berries, dried herbs, tobacco and vanilla. Savoury cherry fruit gives way to grippy, plentiful tannins with an oaky...
2019
TresmanoRibera del Duero
Valdaya, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019
Opulent yet elegant jammy, dark fruit aromas. Plum compote, sour cherry, liquorice and cocoa, with a fruity and fresh core. Intense, toasty and herbal character,...
2019
ValdayaRibera del Duero
Aster, Finca el Otero, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019
Exuberant blueberry, blackberry, damsons, liquorice and mocha aromas. Juicy with forceful intensity, sweetness and toasty oak. Balanced acidity gives way to an attractively dry and...
2019
AsterRibera del Duero
