Sarah Jane Evans MW: My top 10 Spanish wines of 2023
Including fresh vibrant styles from native grapes, bottles from Rioja and Ribera del Duero and a 1975 amontillado Sherry, expert Sarah Jane Evans MW shares her favourite bottles of the year.
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
You are now subscribed
Your newsletter sign-up was successful
2023 has been a great year for lovers of Spanish wine. The choice of wines is terrific. For me, in particular, it’s been a year of properly returning to normal, being able to get out and about and meet producers across the country and the islands, walk the vineyards, taste their wines.
Scroll down to see tasting notes and scores for Sarah-Jane Evans MW’s top 10 wines of 2023
I have travelled this year to the USA, Greece and Japan, and co-chaired the global diversity of the Decanter World Wine Awards. However, I’m limited here to choosing just 10 wines from Spain only. How difficult that is!
My selection began with something that Spain does really well: wines with moderate alcohol and vividly fresh acidity. Red, white and the occasional pale red clarete, all made from local varieties. It’s a surprise for many, when thinking about this apparently hot country, but these are wines that refresh. Galicia excels in them. Cool parts of Catalunya too.
The Xarel-lo variety from Penedés has definitely earned its place on my shelves this year. I’ll be raising a glass of Gramona III Lustros – which is 70% Xarel-lo (30% Macabeo) – to toast the memory of the late Javier Gramona of Gramona winery, who drove the creation of Corpinnat, and who died so suddenly and sadly this year. Also to his son Leo Gramona and nephew Roc Gramona, separately successful with L’Enclòs de Peralba, who are now taking on extra responsibilities as a result.
Southern stars
My choices continue with wines from what has been a year of discovery. My study trip to the welcoming producers of Montilla-Moriles was an eye-opener this year; the history and excellence of the wines from this region have for too long been obscured by their neighbour Jerez.
From Jerez I had to include the extraordinary González Byass Amontillado 1975, a discovery that I savoured in August. It was the final wine in a memorable tasting of aged wines that I hosted with two fellow MWs at Texsom, the international wine conference. It’s a privilege of working in wine to be able to taste and share such treasures, if only very occasionally.
Sparkling performance
Cava is sure to be in my fridge this year. In November I discovered the most recent specialist category of Cava: Elaborador Integral. In the fine chocolate world we would call them ‘bean to bar’ producers: these are winemakers who control the whole process from grape growing to estate bottling. There are 15 of them. One of the most delicious – if the most difficult to store in the fridge because of its awkward height – is Alta Alella. It’s the winery closest to Barcelona, in sight of the sea. The winery’s floral, mineral, saline, single-vineyard Mirgin Exeo Paratge Qualificat Vallcirera is 60% Pansa Blanca (Xarel-lo) with 40% Chardonnay, grown on sauló, granitic sand. It’s a treat.
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
To finish? I had room for jewels from Rioja and Ribera del Duero. But there’s so much more to enjoy: Spain is a treasure store.
Sarah Jane Evans MW: my top wines of 2022
Related content
Best Sherries: top bottles to try
Hidden Spain: tiny wine regions
Galician whites: Panel tasting results
Dominio del Aguila, Albillo Viñas Viejas, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2019

The Albillo variety has only recently been recognised by the Ribera del Duero authorities. Jorge Monzón, the master of purity, stopped me in my tracks...
2019
Castilla y LéonSpain
Dominio del AguilaRibera del Duero
Pazo Barrantes, La Comtesse de Pazo Barrantes, Rías Baixas, Galicia, Spain, 2018

Pazo Barrantes stepped back from the market for a couple of years to refine its Albariños. The return was sensational. The top wine, the Countess,...
2018
GaliciaSpain
Pazo BarrantesRías Baixas
Bodegas Alvear, 3 Miradas Vino de Pueblo, Montilla-Moriles, Spain, 2021

This is the baby of the 3 Miradas family, a village wine from a blend of parcels. Fermented in fino butts and aged in concrete...
2021
Montilla-MorilesSpain
Bodegas Alvear
Celler Pardas, Pur Xarel-lo, Penedès, Northern Spain, Spain, 2020

This lovely Xarel-lo comes from one of its best terroirs in the Alt Penedés. Ramón Porera works here with two vineyards planted in 1965 and...
2020
Northern SpainSpain
Celler PardasPenedès
Bodegas Muga, Prado Enea, Rioja Gran Reserva, Northern Spain, Spain, 2015

Wonderful: a superb Gran Reserva, so finely balanced between the silky tannins and the elegance of maturity. It's fermented in oak, and spends three years...
2015
Northern SpainSpain
Bodegas MugaRioja Gran Reserva
Alvaredos-Hobbs, Mencía, Ribeira Sacra, Galicia, Spain, 2020

A new arrival to Ribeira Sacra’s steep slopes. The project is a joint venture between Galician grower Antonio López and renowned Californian winemaker Paul Hobbs....
2020
GaliciaSpain
Alvaredos-HobbsRibeira Sacra
Adegas Terrae, Barbadelo Mencía, Ribeira Sacra, Galicia, Spain, 2021

One of my value discoveries of the year. Just briefly (three months) oaked, this is a textbook Mencía with its fine interplay of black plums...
2021
GaliciaSpain
Adegas TerraeRibeira Sacra
Sierra de Toloño, Nahikun Tinto, Rioja, Northern Spain, Spain, 2020

Sandra Bravo celebrated her first decade in 2022. Superb, single-minded achievements, working with old vines in Rioja Alavesa. Nahikun is a lively red blend, spicy,...
2020
Northern SpainSpain
Sierra de ToloñoRioja
Gonzalez Byass, Amontillado Añada 1975, Jerez, Spain, 1975

Part of the González Byass treasure house: a vintage 1975. A sensational wine; it bears its almost half century of age with a glorious confidence....
1975
JerezSpain
Gonzalez Byass
Equipo Navazos, I Think Amontillado, Montilla-Moriles, Spain

A very rich roasted hazelnut character makes this hard to resist. Lovely caramel crispness, lemon rind and peach, quite complex. There is a leesy, sea...
Montilla-MorilesSpain
Equipo Navazos

Sarah Jane Evans MW is an award-winning journalist who began writing about wine (and food, restaurants, and chocolate) in the 1980s. She started drinking Spanish wine - Sherry, to be specific - as a student of classics and social and political sciences at Cambridge University. This started her lifelong love affair with the country’s wines, food and culture, leading to her appointment as a member of the Gran Orden de Caballeros de Vino for services to Spanish wine. In 2006 she became a Master of Wine, writing her dissertation on Sherry and winning the Robert Mondavi Winery Award. Currently vice-chairman of the Institute of Masters of Wine, Evans divides her time between contributing to leading wine magazines and reference books, wine education and judging wines internationally.