Confused? Our expert explains...
Brut nature vs zéro dosage
Jiles Halling, via email, asks: What’s the difference between ‘brut nature’ and ‘zéro dosage’?
Tim Hall replies: The ambiguity has arisen because Champagne does not distinguish between, let alone add up, the sugar in the dosage and what might already be in the bottle before disgorgement.
The official sweetness bands, and any precise value on a back label, denote the strength of the dosage liqueur, calculated, measured and confirmed before being squirted into each bottle before the cork.
Brut nature, the official term (technically 0-3g/L of sugar), means no sugar added but there may be some residual, which is ‘natural’.
Why does my extra dry Prosecco taste sweet?
Does putting a spoon in Champagne work?
Do créments age as well as Champagne?
Many people, such as Decanter writer Michael Edwards, think it slightly nebulous but I like the term – but that does not take away the fact that 99% of people who drink Champagne know nothing about dosage or the various terms for it.
Edwards prefers ‘non-dosé’, but I think it sounds medicinal and tells no one exactly what a dose is – or, in this case, not.
Brut zéro/zéro dosage is also ambiguous – effectively a lie because there is always a gram or so of residual sugar not fermented out, as without it you cannot make Champagne.
I quite like ‘Ultra Brut’, but I am sure Laurent- Perrier registered the name long ago.
Tim Hall is a Champagne specialist who is director of wine tour and event company Scala Wine. Edited for Decanter.com by Ellie Douglas.
Read more notes and queries every month in Decanter magazine. Subscribe to the latest issue here
Got a question for Decanter’s experts? Email us: email@example.com or on social media with #askDecanter
More questions answered:
Champagne corks – ask Decanter
Why do Champagne bottles have mushroom-shaped corks..?
Champagne fizz fading – ask Decanter
My Champagne never seems to have much fizz...
Do crémants age as well as Champagne? – Ask Decanter
Does Crémant de Bourgogne age as well as Champagne?
Does putting a spoon in Champagne work? – ask Decanter
Does it keep Champagne sparkling...?
Prosecco vs Champagne: What’s the difference? Ask Decanter
The main differences between these popular sparkling wines.
Why is there no red Champagne? – ask Decanter
Why does my ‘extra dry’ Prosecco taste sweet? – ask Decanter
Sweeter than you thought...?