Panel tasting results: Superb St-Emilion & Pomerol from 2020
Revealing the consistency and quality of such a highly rated vintage in two of the world’s top wine regions, St-Emilion & Pomerol, the sheer number of high scores here tells the story.
Georgie Hindle, Arthur Coggill and Tom King tasted 147 wines, with 3 Exceptional, 32 Outstanding and 98 Highly recommended.
147 wines tasted
Exceptional 3
Outstanding 32
Highly recommended 98
Recommended 14
Commended 0
Fair 0
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
Entry criteria: producers and UK agents were invited to submit their grand vin Pomerol and St-Emilion Grand Cru, Grand Cru Classé or 1er Grand Cru Classé wines from the 2020 vintage
Château St-Georges Côte Pavie
'There wasn’t a wine I didn’t like,’ remarked Tom King after what proved to be one of Decanter’s most successful panel tastings in recent memory, with an extraordinary 35 wines rated Outstanding or above from 147 tasted – clear evidence of the strength and consistency of the 2020 vintage in St-Emilion and Pomerol.
The two-day blind tasting confirmed the quality across the board. Arthur Coggill summed it up neatly: ‘2020 is a homogeneously good vintage in Bordeaux – these are wines you can go and buy with confidence.’
The judges found no outright failures; ‘We didn’t actually find a bad wine,’ he added.
The growing season in 2020 was defined by an unusually early start, extreme heatwaves and the driest summer since 1959 (until the 2022 vintage).
Merlot, the dominant variety on the Right Bank, ripened beautifully under these conditions, yet the wines showed surprising restraint.
Alcohol levels and oak influence were far more moderate than the judges had feared; there were no overworked wines, instead freshness and balance prevailed. Differences between the appellations stood out clearly.
Pomerol offered greater consistency, especially at the lower end, producing plush and fleshy wines that remained faithful to their charming, fruit-forward signature.
‘Pomerol is just a bit more generous,’ observed Coggill. St-Emilion was more diverse and patchy at the entry level, with ‘more mediocre, but not necessarily bad wines’, Coggill noted – largely a reflection of its greater size and varied terroirs.
Yet at the top end, its wines frequently displayed superior elegance and finesse, outperforming Pomerol in poise and length.
St-Emilion Grand Cru Classé estates performed strongly, as expected, but Pomerol’s broader success across all price tiers was particularly striking.
Ready to go
Château Rol Valentin
The drinkability of these wines is a major strength. Many are already highly approachable – ‘happy wines’, as King put it, that will perform well by the glass in restaurants or on the table at home today.
The judges agreed that roughly half the wines felt ready to drink now, while the remainder offer excellent cellaring potential thanks to bright acidity, concentrated fruit and structured tannins.
King highlighted the ‘velvety’ texture of the Pomerols and their surprising accessibility: ‘There was not much in Pomerol at least that I would say has to be kept.’
Prices reflect the fine-wine status of these appellations; very few of the top-scoring bottles sit comfortably under £30, even in bond (before duty and VAT), indeed the very best top £50.
Yet within this category many represent excellent value, offering the immediate pleasure of a great vintage alongside the structure to evolve magnificently over the next 20-30 years.
Overall, the judges described 2020 as a ‘cracking vintage’ of good-to-excellent wines that offer a combination of generosity and restraint.
For drinkers seeking reliable, characterful Right Bank Bordeaux that can be enjoyed young or cellared with confidence, 2020 delivers in spades.
See all the notes and scores from the St-Emilion and Pomerol 2020 tasting here
The judges

Georgie Hindle is Decanter’s Regional Editor for Bordeaux. She lives in the city and is the author of The Smart Traveller’s Wine Guide (£12.99 Académie du Vin Library, 2024)

Arthur Coggill is head of business development for the UK division of New Yorkbased merchant and auction house Acker. Previously in a similar role at merchant Hatton & Edwards, he also ran the investment fund at Goedhuis & Co before moving into buying

Tom King is fine wine manager at The Great Wine Co and Enotria. He first worked in wine at a retail store in St Louis, Missouri, before returning to the UK in late 2000 and taking up a buying and and private client sales role with merchant Great Western Wine
St-Emilion & Pomerol 2020 tasting results
Related articles
Panel tasting results: Great-value Right Bank Bordeaux in the spotlight
Panel tasting results: The best of South Africa's red blends
Panel tasting results: Northern Rhône 2015
Château Canon, St-Emilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired by the Wertheimer family, owners of Chanel, in 1996, Château Canon occupies a prime position on the limestone plateau of St-Emilion. Major vineyard restructuring...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château CanonSt-Emilion
Château St-Georges Côte Pavie, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

This relatively under-the-radar St-Emilion estate has been owned by the same family since 1873. The majority of its vines lie on the prestigious clay-limestone slopes...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château St-Georges Côte PavieSt-Emilion
Clos Fourtet, St-Emilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Purchased by the Cuvelier family in 2001, Clos Fourtet is hard to miss, sitting proudly on the highest limestone plateau overlooking the town of St-Emilion,...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Clos FourtetSt-Emilion
Château Canon-la-Gaffelière, St-Emilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired by Count Joseph-Hubert von Neipperg in 1971 and now managed by his son Stephan, Canon La Gaffelière lies at the foot of the St-Emilion...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Canon-la-GaffelièreSt-Emilion
Château La Dominique, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

La Dominique lies just a stone’s throw from Cheval Blanc and borders several iconic Pomerol estates. The property's outstanding gravelly terroir lured the Fayat family...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château La DominiqueSt-Emilion
Château Vray Croix de Gay, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Vray Croix de Gay traces its roots to the late 19th century when Joseph Brisson assembled the estate around the historic Domaine des Grands Champs...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Vray Croix de GayPomerol
La Mondotte, St-Emilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

This compact 4.5ha vineyard on the clay-limestone plateau east of St-Emilion was acquired by the von Neipperg family in 1971. Stephan von Neipperg transformed the...
2020
BordeauxFrance
La MondotteSt-Emilion
Château Corbin, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Dating back to the 15th century, Château Corbin has been owned by the Cruse family since 1924. Fourth-generation Anabelle Cruse-Bardinet runs the estate with her...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château CorbinSt-Emilion
Château Larmande, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

One of the oldest estates in St-Emilion with records dating to 1585, Château Larmande was given as a wedding gift in the early 20th century...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château LarmandeSt-Emilion
Château Le Gay, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

This historic Pomerol estate was long associated with the Robin family until it was acquired in 2002 by Catherine Péré-Vergé, the influential 'grande dame of...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Le GayPomerol
Château Mazeyres, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired by Sogecap (the insurance arm of Société Générale) in 2010, Mazeyres entered a new chapter in 2020 when the Guillard family – already owners...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château MazeyresPomerol
Château Sansonnet, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Situated on the highest point of the clay-limestone plateau on the doorstep of St-Emilion town, Château Sansonnet once belonged to the Duke Decazes, Prime Minister...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château SansonnetSt-Emilion
Château Bel-Air, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Château Bel-Air has long been guided by Madame Melet (Marie-Françoise Melet, née Sudrat), the respected and dedicated matriarch who has steered the estate for more...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Bel-AirPomerol
Château Bonalgue, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired by the Bourotte family in 1926, Bonalgue forms part of a historic Pomerol portfolio that also includes the family’s renowned négociant house Jean-Baptiste Audy,...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château BonalguePomerol
Château Bourgneuf, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Owned by the Vayron family since 1840, Bourgneuf is now in its eighth generation. Frédérique Vayron and her sister Marie have been at the helm...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château BourgneufPomerol
Château Cadet-Bon, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

This compact 7ha Grand Cru Classé was acquired in 2001 by Michèle and Guy Richard, a couple from wine-growing families in Charente-Maritime who devoted themselves...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Cadet-BonSt-Emilion
Château de Pressac, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Founded in the Middle Ages and promoted to Grand Cru Classé in 2012, Château de Pressac was acquired in 1997 by Jean-François Quenin. The 41ha...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château de PressacSt-Emilion
Château de Sales, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

One of Pomerol’s largest and most historic estates, Château de Sales has been owned by the de Lambert family (descendants of the Sauvanelles) since the...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château de SalesPomerol
Château Fleur Cardinale, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Fleur Cardinale was acquired in 2001 by Dominique and Florence Decoster (from the Limoges porcelain world), and is now mainly run by their son Ludovic...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Fleur CardinaleSt-Emilion
Château Fonplégade, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired in 2004 by Denise and the late Stephen Adams, Fonplégade is now run hands-on by Denise Adams and a dedicated team following her husband’s...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château FonplégadeSt-Emilion
Château Fonroque, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

A St-Emilion Grand Cru Classé whose cellars date back to 1756, Fonroque achieved organic certification in 2006 and became the first Grand Cru Classé in...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château FonroqueSt-Emilion
Château Franc-Maillet, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

This small, family-run estate began after World War I when Jean-Baptiste Arpin, a returning veteran, bought his first hectare in Pomerol on a life annuity....
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Franc-MailletPomerol
Château Grand Corbin-Despagne, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Owned by the Despagne family for more than two centuries across seven generations, Grand Corbin-Despagne lies near Château Cheval Blanc on the northern border of...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Grand Corbin-DespagneSt-Emilion
Château Haut-Sarpe, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Owned by the Janoueix family since 1930, Haut-Sarpe is situated on clay-limestone soils over a limestone bedrock. The 21.5ha vineyard occupies a privileged position on...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Haut-SarpeSt-Emilion
Château Jean Faure, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Classified as a St-Emilion Grand Cru Classé in 2012, Château Jean Faure has been owned by Olivier and Anne Decelle since 2004. The estate stands...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château Jean FaureSt-Emilion
Château La Clemence, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired in 1996 by Christian Dauriac of Vignobles Dauriac, the family behind Châteaux Destieux and Montlisse (both St-Emilion), this is a boutique Pomerol estate located...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château La ClemencePomerol
Château La Croix Toulifaut, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

The vineyards of Château La Croix Toulifaut trace their history back to the Middle Ages, when pilgrims on the route to Santiago de Compostela in...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château La Croix ToulifautPomerol
Château La Croizille, St-Emilion, Grand Cru, Bordeaux, France 2020

Real power and depth on display, some pretty serious and ferocious tannins going on at first. One you need to sit and let uncurl, and...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château La CroizilleSt-Emilion
Château La Tour Figeac, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Located on the famous Figeac plateau in St-Emilion and bordering Château Cheval Blanc, La Tour Figeac has deep historical ties to the area. Owned for...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château La Tour FigeacSt-Emilion
Château La Violette, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

This tiny 1.8ha Pomerol gem on the plateau between Château Trotanoy and Le Pin, on iron-rich dense clay and gravel, was acquired in 2006 by...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château La ViolettePomerol
Château Montviel, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

This is the third of the Péré-Vergé/Parent family-owned Outstanding wines in this panel tasting, alongside Châteaux Le Gay and La Violette. The first of the...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château MontvielPomerol
Château Nénin, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired in 1997 by the Delon family, owners of Châteaux Léoville Las Cases and Potensac on the Left Bank, Château Nénin occupies a fine position...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château NéninPomerol
Château Soutard, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

One of the most beautiful estates in St-Emilion, Soutard traces its history back to 1513, with the château built in 1741. Now a Grand Cru...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château SoutardSt-Emilion
Château Valandraud, St-Emilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2020

Created by Jean-Luc Thunevin and Murielle Andraud initially from a tiny 0.6ha plot (now 10.7ha), Valandraud leapt from 'garage wine' with its first vintage in...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Château ValandraudSt-Emilion
Le Clos du Beau-Pere, Pomerol, Bordeaux, France 2020

Acquired in 2006 by Jean-Luc Thunevin and Murielle Andraud (and renamed in tribute to Murielle’s father), this 4ha estate northeast of Libourne was previously known...
2020
BordeauxFrance
Le Clos du Beau-PerePomerol