best California wines
(Image credit: Credit Unknown)

Twenty years ago, I moved from New York City to the Napa Valley, in the sheer belief that living near vines would make me a better wine writer, and would touch my heart in ways imaginable and not. And I think it has.

When I arrived, I had only a passing knowledge of Californian wines. California seemed a kind of wine Camelot – a place of awesome beauty and high ideals. But to me, the wines were a mystery. For my part, I loved Sancerre and Mosel Rieslings; I craved old Rioja; for me back then, nothing supplanted great Bordeaux.

Slowly, through immersion and maybe osmosis, I’ve come to know California during what has been the most exciting and innovative period in its two-century history. The wines that follow are not the California wines any of us first knew when California began to emerge on the world stage.

California has grown up. There’s still a little Beyoncé in her step, but her inner Grace Kelly has started to be revealed.


See also: Ten rules to food and wine pairing


Here are 10 California wines I find fascinating.

They come from all over the state, from appellations both well known and yet to be known. When each of these wines was first made, it charted new stylistic territory. Since then, in quality and complexity, each has continued to raise California’s bar. All of these wines have been singled out in the new, second edition of The Wine Bible.

Vineyard 29, Sauvignon Blanc, California, USA, 2012

My wines
Locked score

Just a tiny amount of Vineyard 29’s Sauvignon Blanc is made, but it reveals a whole new side of what is possible in the Napa...

2012

CaliforniaUSA

Vineyard 29

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Diatom, Miya Chardonnay, Santa Barbara County, Sta Rita Hills, California, USA, 2011

My wines
Locked score

After I tasted this wine for the first time (in 2012; it was the 2010 vintage), my view of California Chardonnay changed irredeemably. No flaccid...

2011

CaliforniaUSA

DiatomSanta Barbara County

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Sanford, Sanford & Benedict Pinot Noir, Santa Barbara County, Sta Rita Hills, California, USA, 2012

My wines
Locked score

This was the Pinot Noir – the crown jewel – that inspired the entire current generation of southern California winemakers. I first tasted it in...

2012

CaliforniaUSA

SanfordSanta Barbara County

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Failla, Pinot Noir, Hirsch Vineyard, Sonoma County, Sonoma Coast, California, USA, 2012

My wines
Locked score

Ehren Jordan and Anne-Marie Failla (FAY-la), owners of Failla winery, make a handful of exquisite Pinot Noirs from high-elevation, ocean air-cooled vineyards along what insiders...

2012

CaliforniaUSA

FaillaSonoma County

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Roar, Pinot Noir, Monterey County, Santa Lucia Highlands, California, USA, 2013

My wines
Locked score

Saying ‘Roar’ to a California Pinot Noir lover is a little like saying ‘Ferrari’ to an Italian who loves cars. Some of the most luscious,...

2013

CaliforniaUSA

RoarMonterey County

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

The Ojai Vineyard, Solomon Hills Vineyard Syrah, Santa Barbara County, Santa Maria Valley, California, USA, 2013

My wines
Locked score

I’m not sure how a wine can take on the character of a psychological thriller, but this one has. The ‘unhinged’ – almost savage –...

2013

CaliforniaUSA

The Ojai VineyardSanta Barbara County

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Radio-Coteau, Las Colinas Syrah, Sonoma County, Sonoma Coast, California, USA, 2013

My wines
Locked score

Every time I drink Radio-Coteau, I picture – what else? – an old-style radio, and indeed, with Las Colinas (the hillsides), the volume dial is...

2013

CaliforniaUSA

Radio-CoteauSonoma County

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

O'Shaughnessy Estate, Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, California, USA, 2012

My wines
Locked score

This great little number is among the dozens of tiny-production Cabernets made by family-owned wineries, often located high up in Napa Valley’s mountains, a 30-minute...

2012

CaliforniaUSA

O'Shaughnessy EstateNapa Valley

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Scarecrow, Cabernet Sauvignon, California, USA, 2012

My wines
Locked score

Named after the scarecow in the 1939 movie The Wizard of Oz, Scarecrow comes from the historic J J Cohn estate, next door to the...

2012

CaliforniaUSA

Scarecrow

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now
Karen MacNeil
Decanter Magazine, Wine Writer & DWWA Judge
Karen MacNeil is the only American to have won most major wine awards given in the English language. These include the James Beard award for Wine and Spirits Professional of the Year, the Louis Roederer award for Best Consumer Wine Writing and the Wine Appreciation Guild’s Wine Literary Award. She is author of the award-winning book , (now in its third edition), which has sold more than one million copies worldwide. The former wine correspondent for the , on NBC, she was also host of the PBS television series ,, for which she won an Emmy. Along with running her own customised wine experience company, MacNeil is additionally a public speaker (in person and virtually), creator of digital newsletter , and teaches a continuing education course on wine at Stanford University. MacNeil was the Regional Chair for USA & Central America at the Decanter World Wine Awards (DWWA) 2018, and also recently launched a line of glassware, the Flavor First Collection.