Panel tasting results: 30 mightily impressive English sparkling wines
The development of greater stocks of reserve wines means that UK sparkling producers are now able to make increasing quantities of non- and multi-vintage wines – and the results have clearly impressed our judges.
Susie Barrie MW, Matt Hodgson and Dror Nativ MW tasted 66 wines, with 11 Outstanding and 40 Highly recommended
English sparkling wine: Panel tasting scores
66 wines tasted
Exceptional 0
Outstanding 11
Highly recommended 40
Recommended 14
Commended 1
Fair 0
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
Entry criteria: producers and UK agents were invited to submit their current-release brut or drier-style white, rosé or red traditional-method sparkling wines, single varietals or blends, produced in the UK using a blend of multiple vintages and labelled as non-vintage or multi-vintage
It was the year of the London Olympics, not to mention Queen Elizabeth ll’s Diamond Jubilee celebrations.
But for UK wine, 2012 was an annus horribilis on a scale hitherto unseen in the modern era.
When a vintage that bad comes along, having a stock of reserve wines to draw on is an essential blending tool in any traditional-method sparkling winemaker’s arsenal.
Sadly, given the nascency of the UK industry at that time, very few wineries had a reserve wine programme.
But as Hattingley Valley’s then head winemaker Emma Rice said: ‘2012 spurred us on to do it’.
Fast forward to today and the industry has evolved from producing largely single-vintage wines to one where non-vintage (NV) and multi-vintage (MV) bottlings play a growing role.
Hence this panel tasting, which also perfectly demonstrated how quality is rising seemingly exponentially.
As Dror Nativ MW stated: ‘If you consider the number of high scores we gave today, there’s really smart, consistent winemaking in England.’
Depth of flavour
Matt Hodgson concurred, adding: ‘I think non- and multi-vintage is the right direction of travel for the English wine industry’, and all the judges agreed that the wines containing higher levels of reserves (or just based on older vintages) delivered greater complexity and depth of flavour.
It’s also worth mentioning that almost all the wines we rated Outstanding (95 points or more) had seen oak and spent considerable time on lees, which added further layers of flavour.
One noteworthy observation was the way in which the whites outperformed the rosé wines (of the 30 wines scoring 93-96pts, only eight were rosé).
Hodgson commented: ‘We’ve always been big advocates of English sparkling rosé [at retailer Grape Britannia] and they were great – it’s just the whites were even better.’
Beyond quality, what I find exciting is that, in the key sweet spot of £30-£50, the best UK wines offer excellent value.
As Nativ said: ‘Based on the tasting today, we saw brilliant value compared to either Champagne or any worldclass sparkling wines.’
I couldn’t agree more.
What to eat with UK sparkling wines, by Fiona Beckett
Given that English fizz is of a similar quality to Champagne these days, is there anything to say about partnering them with food other than that they should work with similar dishes to Champagne?
That’s undeniably true, but it’s also good to think about how you might drink them from an English perspective.
Fish and chips is often trotted out – nothing wrong with that – but these quality wines would be excellent with more elevated seafood-based dishes such as grilled lobster, seared scallops or salmon en croute (sparkling wine has a real affinity with pastry).
There’s no reason why you can’t take them further afield, too. The impressive low- or no-dosage English sparkling would be great with raw fish dishes such as sushi, sashimi and carpaccio.
When it comes to English sparkling rosé, what about a summery Sunday lunch with rare roast fillet of beef or a butterflied leg of lamb, again rare, maybe cooked over coals?
Rosy-pink red meat is a surprisingly good match for sparkling rosé.
See all notes and scores from the UK sparkling wines tasting
The judges

Susie Barrie MW is a wine writer and broadcaster who regularly appears on Saturday Kitchen, Daily Cooks and Great Food Live. She has also spoken on BBC Radio Two, LBC Radio and BBC Radio Scotland. As an author, she has penned Mitchell Beazley's Wine Made Easy 'Champagne and Sparkling Wines', as well as Discovering Wine Country - Northern Spain. Aside from Decanter, she contributes to The Sunday Times Magazine. She gives lectures and judges international wine competitions. Alongside her husband, Peter Richard MW, she runs the Winchester Wine School. They have their own website, susieandpeter.com.

Matt Hodgson is owner of retailer Grape Britannia, which he founded in 2019 to focus on the English and Welsh wine industry, going on to win multiple Decanter Retailer Awards as specialist in this region. He is a judge at the WineGB Awards

Dror Nativ MW is a wine buyer for major retailer Marks & Spencer, responsible for South America as well as Bordeaux, Burgundy, England, Champagne and sparkling wine. Having begun his career in the hospitality sector, he has also worked in varying roles at Hayward Bros, Spar and Sainsbury’s.
UK sparkling wines panel tasting results:
Wines were tasted blind
Related articles
Vintage English sparkling wine: Panel tasting results
Best English and Welsh wines to try
‘Rolling all of Wales’ talent and natural resources into the same conversation as England misses the point ’
Mountfield Winery, Blanc de Blancs Brut, East Sussex, England, United Kingdom NV

In 2012, Lucinda and Simon Fraser planted a 3.5ha vineyard on their mixed livestock and arable family farm in the Rother valley, East Sussex. They...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Mountfield WineryEast Sussex
Wiston Estate, Brut, West Sussex, England, United Kingdom NV

Originally established by Pip and Harry Goring with Dermot Sugrue as winemaker, Wiston is now under the custodianship of the next Goring family generation, son...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Wiston EstateWest Sussex
Ambriel, Classic Brut, West Sussex, England, United Kingdom NV

The 9.5ha south-facing Ambriel vineyard in West Sussex sits on greensand rock: ‘Our secret weapon,’ says owner Wendy Outhwaite. Everything is done onsite, farming is...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
AmbrielWest Sussex
Simpsons, Chalklands Classic Cuvée Extended Lees Ageing Brut, Kent, England, United Kingdom NV

This year sees the 10th anniversary of Ruth and Charles Simpsons’ first vintage from their Kentish winery in Barham, near Canterbury, the only one in...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
SimpsonsKent
Domaine Hugo, Hugo Single Vineyard Brut Nature, Wiltshire, England United Kingdom NV

Domaine Hugo is one of a handful of seriously impressive wineries to emerge from Wiltshire in recent years. The organically and biodynamically certified vineyard was...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Domaine HugoWiltshire
Exton Park, RB45 Blanc de Blancs Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Since her arrival at Exton Park in 2011, French winemaker Corinne Seely has been a vocal advocate for the use of reserve wines – earlier...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Exton ParkHampshire
Hambledon, Première Cuvée Brut, Hampshire, England, NV

Founded in 1952, Hambledon was the first commercial vineyard of the modern English wine era. In 1999 it was acquired by financier Ian Kellett, who...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
HambledonHampshire
Harrow & Hope, Reserve No 10 Brut, Buckinghamshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Harrow & Hope is a name that tends to fly under the radar, but Henry and Kaye Laithwaite have been making terrific sparkling wines from...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Harrow & HopeBuckinghamshire
Smith & Evans, Higher Plot Trilogy 2 Extra Brut, Somerset, England, United Kingdom NV

If you’ve always dreamed of owning a ‘small but perfectly formed vineyard’, as Guy Smith describes it, now could be your chance, as Smith &...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Smith & EvansSomerset
Sugrue South Downs, The Trouble with Dreams Extra Brut, England, United Kingdom NV

The formidable team of Dermot and Ana Sugrue acquired their own vineyard in East Sussex in 2023. Having established a winery, their portfolio now includes...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Sugrue South Downs
Candover Brook, Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Deep gold and gently fragrant – baked apple, red apple skin and glazed apricot, pastry cream and nutty brioche. Fine mousse and expressive length bring...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Candover BrookHampshire
Hattingley Valley, Classic Reserve Brut, England, United Kingdom NV

Lemon curd and brioche. Elegant, with orchard fruit and toasted almond gliding over a fine, persistent mousse. Dry, savoury and beautifully integrated, finishing understated yet...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Hattingley Valley
Sugrue South Downs, Bee Tree by Sugrue Blanc de Noirs Brut, United Kingdom NV

Golden and generous, layering honey, spice, toast and orchard fruit over bright lemon and red apple. Concentrated yet poised, with cinnamon and apple skin carrying...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Sugrue South Downs
Wiston Estate, Blanc de Blancs Brut, West Sussex, England, United Kingdom NV

Savoury yeast and pastry aromas give way to peach, citrus and baked spice, lifted by fine bubbles and a creamy custard note. Fruit-forward yet composed,...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Wiston EstateWest Sussex
Coates & Seely, Blanc de Blancs Brut, England, United Kingdom NV

Savoury and mineral, showing toasted almond, baked bread and lime pickle before an intense palate of green apple, citrus, white flower and spice. Fine mousse...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Coates & Seely
Denbies, Greenfields Brut, England, United Kingdom NV

Bready and biscuity with a Champagne-like feel. Shortbread, gingerbread and apple pie over ripe apple, raisin and patisserie. Creamy and generous with long, lees-aged appeal.
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Denbies
Exton Park, RB28 Blanc de Noirs Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Yeasty and creamy, with apple crumble, citrus zest and orchard fruit unfolding through a persistent mousse. Broad red fruit, brioche and a soft dairy note....
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Exton ParkHampshire
The Grange, Classic Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Restrained yet well knit, offering bread, herbs and white flowers over apricot, orchard fruit, red apple and bramble. Bright acidity and gentle spice keep it...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
The GrangeHampshire
Hambledon, Classic Cuvée Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Deeply satisfying, with toasted nuts, pastry and oatcake wrapped around bruised apple and orchard fruit. Bold yet well knit, showing bottle age and a complex,...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
HambledonHampshire
Langham, Blanc de Blancs Brut, Dorset, England, United Kingdom NV

Characterful and dry, with toasted nuts, baked bread and digestive biscuit framing green apple and stewed orchard fruits. Saline hints and gentle spice. Bright and...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
LanghamDorset
Sugrue South Downs, Rock Story Extra Brut, England, United Kingdom NV

Soft peach, ripe citrus and apple meet pastry, toasted nut and gingerbread in an inviting, easygoing style. Fresh, brisk and creamy, with lively charm and...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Sugrue South Downs
Woodchurch, Classic Brut, Kent, England, United Kingdom NV

Elegant and creamy, with bread, fresh pastry and grilled almond around white peach, yellow plum and a citrus medley of lemon, lime and grapefruit. Persistent...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
WoodchurchKent
Langham, Rosé Extra Brut, Dorset, England, United Kingdom NV

Although only one Outstanding-rated rosé emerged from this tasting, the judges were not surprised to find it was from Langham – a shining star in...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
LanghamDorset
Britpop, Rosé Brut, Dorset, England, United Kingdom NV

Smoky, savoury and bready, opening into ripe strawberry, red cherry and raspberry. Creamy yet mouthwatering, with hazelnut, white pepper and toast adding depth. Long and...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
BritpopDorset
Hambledon, Première Cuvée Rosé Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Deep salmon. Savoury and evolved, with cream, mushroom and hazelnut alongside dried red fruit, stewed rhubarb and forest floor. Fresh yet complex, structured, persistent, impressively...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
HambledonHampshire
Coates & Seely, Rosé Brut, England, United Kingdom NV

Pale pink. Vibrant, with raspberry, plum, cranberry and peach brightened by pastry notes. Fresh, fruit-led, with lively energy and fine length.
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Coates & Seely
Exton Park, RB23 Rosé Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Developed salmon-pink. Sour cherry, raspberry and cranberry wrapped in brioche, toasted almond and herbs. Layered, elegant and flavoursome. Lovely depth and a long, poised finish.
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Exton ParkHampshire
The Grange, Pink Brut, Hampshire, England, United Kingdom NV

Feather-light, with bready autolysis framing wild strawberry, raspberry, cranberry and plum. Fresh, elegant and moreish, this glides along with lovely poise and a refreshing finish.
EnglandUnited Kingdom
The GrangeHampshire
Greyfriars Vineyard, Rosé Brut, Surrey, England, United Kingdom NV

Pale salmon-pink. Crowd-pleasing, combining smoky breadiness with wild cherry, strawberry, mulberry and red apple skin. Creamy mousse and savoury depth bring texture.
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Greyfriars VineyardSurrey
Wiston Estate, Rosé Brut, West Sussex, England, United Kingdom NV

Bold and expressive, brimming with plum, wild cherry, raspberry and cranberry, then edged by brioche, cream and a savoury, nutty twist. Juicy, driven and persistent,...
EnglandUnited Kingdom
Wiston EstateWest Sussex

Susie Barrie MW is a wine writer and broadcaster who regularly appears on Saturday Kitchen, Daily Cooks and Great Food Live. She has also spoken on BBC Radio Two, LBC Radio and BBC Radio Scotland. As an author, she has penned Mitchell Beazley's Wine Made Easy 'Champagne and Sparkling Wines', as well as Discovering Wine Country - Northern Spain. Aside from Decanter, she contributes to The Sunday Times Magazine. She gives lectures and judges international wine competitions. Alongside her husband, Peter Richard MW, she runs the Winchester Wine School. They have their own website, susieandpeter.com.