1996 Piedmont wines: A retrospective

‘1996 is one of the best vintages of the last century,’ declares Fontanafredda’s winemaker Danilo Drocco. ‘The problem is that it came right before 1997.’ The latter was much hotter and its seductively flamboyant, open-knit wines initially overshadowed the more austere offerings of 1996. But it is this cooler vintage that’s lauded today and its wines have outlived most of the 1997s. [subscriber-content]The growing season in 1996 was unpredictable and proved quite challenging. The summer months were cool and cloudy, with their fair share of rain. But in Piedmont, it is September that really counts and the weather suddenly became warm, dry and breezy. Apart from a heavy two-day downpour later that month, ideal conditions continued through until harvest, which lasted well into October. Complex and powerfully structured, the wines have taken years to come around. I remember sampling a number of them soon after their release and thought I had hit a brick wall. They were unrelentingly backward with searing acidity and arduous tannins. The tasting Almost 20 years later, I had the opportunity to check in on this storied vintage at a retrospective tasting in Vancouver, Canada in early February. It was organised by Peter Rae at International Cellars, a local importer responsible for bringing in some of the top names from Piedmont, and Vancouver-raised Ray Signorello, proprietor of Signorello Estate in Napa Valley. Most of the wines hailed from Signorello’s private collection amassed directly from the wineries on his travels. The remainder (Paolo Scavino, E Pira & Figli, Ceretto, Domenico Clerico and Gaja) were contributed by attending collectors who purchased bottles upon release. The event was held at Lupo Restaurant – a staple for Italian cuisine in Vancouver since opening its doors in 1994. (This is where my own Italian wine education began when I started waiting tables there in 1996, coincidentally.) We tasted through the 13 wines on their own, before enjoying them with a Piemontese-inspired dinner. Winemaking philosophy While the tasting was not designed to be a comparison of modern versus traditional wines, it is impossible to speak of the 1996 vintage without considering distinct winemaking philosophies of that period. This was the zenith of Piedmont's modern revolution, epitomised by the ‘Barolo Boys’. It is symbolised by the renunciation of large, old Slavonian oak casks (the traditional ageing vessel of choice in Piedmont) and the espousal of small French oak barriques, often new. However, proponents also adopted non-traditional techniques such as rotary fermentations and short maceration times of mere days. The goal was to craft wines with greater international and immediate appeal. The most extreme examples have since been criticised – not just for winemaking obscuring grape and place but also for a poor ability to age. The wines tasted fell predominately into the modern camp and included bona fide ‘Barolo Boys’ – producers like Luciano Sandrone, Paolo Scavino and Domenico Clerico. More traditional examples were represented by Brovia, Bruno Giacosa and Aldo Conterno. However, even the latter estate was using rotary fermenters and doing macerations as brief as one week in the mid-1990s. The verdict Overall, the wines have aged well, especially those in magnum. The stamina of the vintage was evident. And rather than one style ageing better than the other, in this tasting it depended on each individual producer. However, the most generously oaked wines made themselves known. The wood is still apparent, especially in the chunky nature of the tannins, even after 24 years. These wines in particular I would drink now while they still have the fruit to balance. The top wines of the vintage will continue to age. In terms of personal preferences, Ceretto’s Brunate was among my favourites for its sheer, undemanding drinking pleasure. I was also charmed by Luciano Sandrone’s Le Vigne, the most gorgeously textured and perfumed wine on the table. The two most impressive wines were Gaja’s Sperss and Giacosa’s Falletto di Serralunga. Essentially opposite in personality, the former bolted out of the glass, almost stubborn in its power; while the latter snuck up gradually. The tasting also included two Barbarescos and I was pleased to see Albino Rocca’s Vigneto Loreto hanging on gracefully. Added perspective The event was held just days after I had returned from Italy for Nebbiolo Prima, which included a showing of the highly acclaimed 2016 Barolo. These new wines fresh on my palate provided great perspective. Since the late 1990s, winemakers in the Langhe continued adapting their practices and the pendulum has swung the other way. Most have reduced or abandoned new oak, some have returned to or incorporated large vessels, and long macerations have made a comeback. ‘I was in full experimental mode,’ recalls E Pira & Figli’s Chiara Boschis of the 1996 vintage. At the time, she was using 100% new barriques but has now reduced that to a maximum of 30% along with introducing larger casks of 2,000 litres. Today the lines between modern and traditional are blurred. Rather than two definitive sides, it is a continuum. These wines from 1996 therefore offer a snapshot of bygone, but very important, era that was significant in the Langhe’s evolution. [/subscriber-content] 1996 Piedmont: The wines [wine-collection]

PREMIUM

1996 Piedmont: A retrospective

1996 Piedmont: The wines

Latest Wine News

Vandals target French wine estate as protests escalate

Châteauneuf-du-Pape: Revisiting 2020 in bottle

Macallan fails to sell in Hong Kong auction

2023 Chablis Vintage Report on Decanter Premium

Burgundy gets new premier cru sites in the Mâconnais

Latest Premium Content

Anderson Valley Pinot Noir: A look at the 2021 vintage

Chablis 2023: Vintage report and best of the new wines

Priorat: An enthralling new wave arises

An interview with Château Margaux’s Alexis Leven-Mentzelopoulos

A lunch with Louis Mitjavile of L’Aurage