St-Emilion GCC 2016
(Image credit: Credit Unknown)

Georgie Hindle, Vincenzo Arnese and Arthur Coggill tasted 59 wines with 11 Outstanding and 41 Highly recommended.

St-Emilion GCC 2016: Panel tasting scores

Exceptional 0

Outstanding 11

Highly recommended 41

Recommended 7

Commended 0

Fair 0

Poor 0


Entry criteria: producers and UK agents were invited to submit 2016-vintage wines from St-Emilion at the grand cru classé and premier grand cru classé A and B levels according to the official Classification of 2012. Second wines (grand cru) of the property were also permitted.


Even having anticipated good results from one of the most highly regarded vintages in Bordeaux over the last two decades, all the judges summarised this as an ‘incredible tasting’ with ‘no bad wines’ among those tasted. It’s a testament to the confidence of estates (and their regard for Decanter’s tasting process) that they were happy to send their critically acclaimed, and in some cases extremely expensive wines to be judged blind for one of our panel tastings, and I am so grateful to them that they did.


Scroll down to see tasting notes and scores from the St-Emilion GCC 2016 panel tasting


In this instance, many wines delivered on an expectation of greatness, with both Arthur Coggill and Vincenzo Arnese admiring the ‘consistency of quality’ across the board. ‘It was a great tasting – a set of really succulent, well-formed wines that you just want to take home and enjoy,’ Coggill remarked. Arnese agreed on the ‘clear drinkability on offer’, especially among those that demonstrated a ‘more juicy, delicate, playful aspect with freshness and excellent oak integration’.

‘It was a vintage with abundant tannin potential and the key was how they were managed,’ Arnese observed. ‘The best wines were those that had seamless tannins and where the oak spice was complementary, lifting the expression rather than dominating it,’ said Coggill.

Many wines revealed terroir nuance, racy acidity and fruit purity. Arnese remarked that ‘there seemed to be a confidence in them that delivered a certain less-is-more style – the others maybe wanted to show more-is-more’, which resulted in some cases of extreme power, concentration, overextraction or overmaturity.

Judges were unaware of wines’ classification status during the tasting, yet the results show a correlation between the quality tiers, with only one non-premier grand cru classé estate among the 11 top-scoring wines, and seven of the 10 second wines present having correspondingly lower scores at 88-90 points.

The judges noted a clear step up in quality at the 95pt mark, with wines demonstrating better integration of oak and tannin management as well as general focus, vibrancy and structure. Many of these wines have decades of drinking pleasure ahead of them.


See all 59 wines from the St-Emilion GCC 2016 panel tasting


‘If you love St-Emilion it’s worth picking up the middle tranche of wines [92pts upwards] or spending a bit more for the top-scoring wines,’ Coggill said. Do keep in mind though that in many instances you’ll need to purchase these wines in full-case quantities and possibly in bond. Many of these wines are just entering the beginning of their drinking windows, so as stocks begin to dwindle it underlines the appeal of purchasing early, en primeur – a consideration for the newly released 2022s – and serves as a good guide for those of you who have these wines in your cellar.

Some estates and Bordeaux négociants do also keep reserve stocks, so you can, if you wish, try contacting them directly, or otherwise ask your merchant to assist.


St-Emilion GCC 2016 panel tasting scores


The judges

Georgie Hindle is Decanter’s regional editor for Bordeaux and Burgundy, and editor of Decanter Premium online. She lives in Bordeaux.

Vincenzo Arnese is the newly appointed director of wine at Raffles London at the OWO. Born in Naples, he specialised in sommellerie at hospitality school, then worked at top hotels in Italy, Switzerland and Australia, as well as in London at Dinner by Heston Blumenthal and Alain Ducasse at The Dorchester.

Arthur Coggill is associate director and fine wine buyer at Goedhuis & Co, Decanter Retailer Awards 2022 Bordeaux Specialist winner. He started in wine at Majestic before moving into fine wine trading in 2010, joining Goedhuis & Co in 2013 and running its sister investment fund Vintage Capital for eight years, before moving solely to buying in 2021.


Château Bélair-Monange, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

JP Moueix bought this 26ha estate next to Château Ausone in 2008. The château was previously known as Bélair, and Christian Moueix added Monange –...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Bélair-MonangeSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Figeac, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France 2016

My wines
Locked score

This is strikingly intense on the nose, with exquisite and perfumed blackcurrant fruit that is clear and pure. The attack is fresh and highly...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château FigeacSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Trotte Vieille, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Run by Philippe Castéja, CEO of his family négociant house Borie-Manoux who bought the estate in 1947. An unusually large proportion of the 12ha vineyard,...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Trotte VieilleSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Angélus, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé A, 2016

My wines
Locked score

A premier grand cru classé A in the St-Emilion Classification since 2012, Angélus removed itself from the controversial system before the 2022 rankings. A family...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château AngélusSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Beauséjour Duffau-Lagarrosse, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classe, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Joséphine Duffau-Lagarrosse is the ninth generation at this estate, in the family since 1847. In 2021, when 30 other family shareholders wanted to sell, she...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Beauséjour Duffau-LagarrosseSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Valandraud, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

One of the early micro-wineries, named after the surname of Murielle Andraud, co-founder with her husband Jean-Luc Thunevin. From their purchase in 1991 of a...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château ValandraudSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château de Pressac, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

This château was the site of the English surrender in 1453 at the end of the Hundred Years War. Owned since 1997 by JeanFrançois and...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château de PressacSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Larcis Ducasse, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Owned by the Gratiot-Attmane family since 1893, Nicolas Thienpont has managed this estate, which abuts Pavie, since 2002, supported by winemaker David Suire and Julien...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Larcis DucasseSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Pavie, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé A, Bordeaux, France 2016

My wines
Locked score

A monumental Pavie. Incredible aromatic intensity, depth and energy; alive, bright and beautifully poised. Packed with power, precision and tension, yet silky smooth, sharp and...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château PavieSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Pavie Macquin, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

A 15ha estate owned by the Corre family, descendants of Albert Macquin, who bought the property in 1887 and was the first in St-Emilion to...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Pavie MacquinSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Dassault, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Smoked cherries, dark chocolate spice, black cherry and currant with liquorice aromas. Supple and generous with great freshness and persistence. Plumy richness with blackcurrant leaves...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château DassaultSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Destieux, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Ripe, fragranced black fruit with coffee beans and dark chocolate on the nose. Juicy, bright and vibrant with a core of dark, bramble fruit. Liquorice,...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château DestieuxSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Sansonnet, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Jammy with sweet spice, blackcurrant and tomato leaves on the nose. Plum, wild raspberry, strawberry and cherry fruit core. Layers of fruit, acidity, fine tannins...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château SansonnetSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Moulin du Cadet, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Blackcurrant, dark cherry and prune with notes of coffee and cedar on the nose. Supple, bouncy, juicy and friendly with an iron tang, fig and...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Moulin du CadetSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Clos Dubreuil, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Smoke, tobacco, cigar box, graphite, mingle with coffee, dark chocolate, and bright cherry fruit. A touch meaty, with fragranced purple flowers and ripe dark berry...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Clos DubreuilSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Soutard, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France, 2016

My wines
Locked score

<p>Among the wines tasted for this article, this is the first vintage where things fall into place, with greater fruit purity – autumnal red berry...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château SoutardSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Yon-Figeac, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Seriously fragranced and aromatic, with cassis, dried fig, prune and raisin. Cedar and clove spice gently mask the bright, red berry fruit. Dense, supple and...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Yon-FigeacSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Trotte Vieille, Dame de Trotte Vieille, St-Émilion Grand Cru. Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Second label. Vibrant with black floral fruit and sweet spice aromas, intense and powerful. Juicy, fresh strawberries and cherries with layers of liquorice and clove....

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Trotte VieilleSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Balestard La Tonnelle, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Lovely, elegant ripe fruit on the nose with perfumed bramble, redcurrant and floral spice aromas. Chestnut and tobacco leaves are layered with plump cherry, strawberry...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Balestard La TonnelleSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Cap de Mourlin, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Dark bramble, blackcurrant, liquorice, plum and cedar spice on the nose. Lithe, supple and juicy on the palate, so mouthwatering but also a touch dry...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Cap de MourlinSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château de Ferrand, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France, 2016

My wines
Locked score

A bouquet of roasted plum, blueberry, shaved almond and vanilla reflect the richness and coolness of the 2016 vintage. With a broad attack, the palate...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château de FerrandSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Fleur Cardinale, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Perfumed, lifted blueberry, blackcurrant and sweet spice on the nose. Smooth and supple, succulent, almost sweet - like blueberry jam. Mocha and dark chocolate with...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Fleur CardinaleSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Grand Mayne, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Smoky sweet spice with juicy, ripe red berries on the nose. The core of liquorice and star anise is supported by plump, fleshy vibrant loganberry...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Grand MayneSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château La Marzelle, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Woody spice with perfumed roses, violets, dark chocolate, and blackcurrants. Sleek and refined, this has a lovely texture with mocha hits, dark cherry and plum....

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château La MarzelleSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château La Tour Figeac, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Potent blackcurrant and black cherry, dark cocoa and cedar nose. Supple and lifted with blueberry and wild plum, redcurrant, menthol and graphite. Nicely controlled and...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château La Tour FigeacSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Larmande, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Heady and ripe, dark fruits, cassis, liquorice with clove spice and blackcurrant aromas. Juicy but quite savoury, liquorice, clove, and toasted oak flavours mingle with...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château LarmandeSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Pavie Decesse, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Open and expressive with notes of smoke, black fruits and heady floral aromas. Racy and vibrant, with an intense richness of black and blue fruits....

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Pavie DecesseSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Villemaurine, St-Émilion, Grand Cru Classé, 2016

My wines
Locked score

Black fruit and red cherry with lifted spice and cedar smoke on the nose. Raspberry coulis and loganberry with a salty, graphite, pencil-lead tang on...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château VillemaurineSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Petit Faurie de Soutard, St-Émilion, Grand Cru, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Ripe plum and sweet spice with hints of smoky wood and black cherry on the nose. Crunchy, bright and vibrant on the palate. Fleshy, with...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Petit Faurie de SoutardSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Angélus, Carillon d'Angelus, St-Émilion, Grand Cru, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Second label. Inviting aromas of ripe black fruit, floral, raspberry leaf and wet stone. Red fruits dominate the palate with a soft, juicy and chewy...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château AngélusSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Château Troplong Mondot, St-Émilion, 1er Grand Cru Classé, Bordeaux 2016

My wines
Locked score

Ripe, heady, full and rich with Christmas cake and nutty caramel on the nose. Delicate blue fruits, blackcurrant with textured, chalky, grippy tannins. Concentrated and...

2016

BordeauxFrance

Château Troplong MondotSt-Émilion

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now