DEC280.winter_warmers.gettyimages_1294054197_credit_istock_getty_images_plus.jpg
Credit: iStock / Getty Images Plus
(Image credit: iStock / Getty Images Plus)

The classic idea of a winter warmer is a red with generous booze to give your internal thermometer a comforting upward nudge. Grapes with a naturally spicy character such as Zinfandel, Syrah and Carmenère often get the nod. But I’ve also included some oak-amplified classics along with robust southern French blends, the odd white with a flex of powerful oak, a white Châteauneuf-du-Pape that should come with the offer of free glee on the label such is its deliciousness, as well as plenty of bottles from warmer climes that possess exuberance and generosity in equal measure.


Scroll down to see tasting notes and scores for Olly Smith’s top 30 wines perfect for winter


I’ve also included a few bottles that perhaps aren’t what would be traditionally thought of as winter warmers, such as Tim Wildman’s Astro Bunny, which is an orange-hued pét-nat wine from Australia. Partly I thought a fizz might be fun; I also happen to love the wine for its outrageously characterful dynamism – ever tasted a sparkling blend of Zibibbo, Fiano, Arneis, Nero d’Avola and Mataro before? Me neither – and its gingery twinkle is the ultimate ignition to spark your refreshment rockets on even the frostiest day.

Tavel Rosé is another one-off inclusion from the pink department. With a more robust style and great with food, I reach for it when the weather is crisp and adore its festive berry hue, too. I’ve even got here a French white Riesling blend, at just 9.5% alcohol, which has a brightness designed to lift any darkling day. And, of course, I wanted to include a range of production methods from ripasso to extended maturation, bottle age to rampaging levels of youthful fruit. And the prices vary, too, from £5 to just shy of a hundred quid. Something, I hope, for everyone.

Insulation for the soul

With the exception of a stonking-value Pedro Ximénez, I’ve skipped fortified wines. Of course I’m a fan of Port, Sherry and Madeira (see Expert’s choice), and they unquestionably deserve all the praise the wine world can give them. I did also think about sweet wines and snuck in an epic icon – who wouldn’t want to sip a glass of Vin de Constance when the weather’s impertinent inclemency can feel so unrelenting? Sweeter than the second coming of Elvis himself and just as memorable, it’s the kind of wine that we all ought to gather round this year and merely marvel at, such is its beauty. A light in these dusky times, and a reminder that wine is so much more than grapes. It’s the liquid that speaks to us in universal ways and I’m increasingly wondering whether only music can ever come quite as close.

In the northern hemisphere as we go to press, this year’s juice is making its way towards becoming wine. In the southern hemisphere, this year’s buds are beginning to think about becoming next year’s grapes. Wine never stands still; wine flows; even when it quietly moves through the stillness of a cellar, you can always catch it in a fresh context, an iteration to beguile, impress, disappoint or bemuse.

Food pairing is one such angle, and I’ve included a few suggestions with some of these recommendations. But the principal variable is, of course, you. These 30 choices will warm you in their various ways this winter, and how you choose to enjoy them depends on your internal weathervane as much as the temperature outside.


Olly Smith’s top 30 winter warmers

Wines have been ordered by price, style and score: over £20, then under £20.


Explore More

Tim Wildman, Astro Bunny Pét-Nat, Adelaide Hills, South Australia, Australia, 2021

My wines
Locked score

A bright, moreish and pure pét-nat, with very well defined aromas of peach, passionfruit, apricot, red apple and bergamot. An edge of angostura bitters gives...

2021

South AustraliaAustralia

Tim WildmanAdelaide Hills

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Domaine du Père Caboche, Blanc, Châteauneuf-du-Pape, Rhône, France, 2021

My wines
Locked score

If ever you needed a reminder of summer’s full flush to cheer you through the teeth of winter, this white Châteauneuf-du-Pape should be top of...

2021

RhôneFrance

Domaine du Père CabocheChâteauneuf-du-Pape

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Pegasus Bay, Chardonnay, Waihopai Valley, Canterbury, New Zealand, 2018

My wines
Locked score

This is gorgeous work from a family estate established in 1986. Beautifully integrated struck match and toasted pine nut aromas. Pumice too. Minerally as well...

2018

CanterburyNew Zealand

Pegasus BayWaihopai Valley

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Trinity Hill, Homage, Gimblett Gravels, Hawke’s Bay, New Zealand, 2018

My wines
Locked score

Coming from the sought-after stoney soils of Gimblett Gravels, winemaker Warren Gibson is one of New Zealand’s true Syrah maestros. Homage is a true classic,...

2018

Hawke’s BayNew Zealand

Trinity HillGimblett Gravels

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Viñalba, Viñalba Cuvée Diane, Mendoza, Argentina, 2017

My wines
Locked score

Extraordinary levels of colour extraction instantly draw the eye to cinematic purple intensity in the glass. Crafted by Hervé J Fabre - original Malbec pioneer...

2017

MendozaArgentina

Viñalba

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Emiliana, Coyam, Colchagua Valley, Chile, 2019

My wines
Locked score

The first time I visited Alvaro Espinoza in Colchagua in October 2007, he explained how Biodynamic wine practice mimicked the ebb and flow of natural...

2019

Colchagua ValleyChile

Emiliana

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Smith & Sheth, Cru Heretaunga Syrah, Hawke’s Bay, New Zealand, 2019

My wines
Locked score

Smith & Sheth offer superb value from Hawke’s Bay with this polished and vibrant Syrah. The tension of Gimblett Gravels comes through on the palate,...

2019

Hawke’s BayNew Zealand

Smith & Sheth

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Tikveš, Barovo, Single Vineyard, Tikves, North Macedonia, 2019

My wines
Locked score

It’s a winter warmer alright! In fact, it’s more of a winter power station of a wine. Enormous, deeply coloured in the glass with gusts...

2019

TikvesNorth Macedonia

Tikveš

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Mas Gabinèle, Faugères, Languedoc-Roussillon, France, 2019

My wines
Locked score

Named after ‘unà gabinelà’ which is a local word for a vineyard hut, this peppery red with striking garrigue fragrance is evolving beautifully. With its...

2019

Languedoc-RoussillonFrance

Mas GabinèleFaugères

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Craggy Range, Te Kahu Single Vineyard, Gimblett Gravels, Hawke’s Bay, New Zealand, 2019

My wines
Locked score

54% Merlot, 27% Cabernet Sauvignon, 10% Malbec, 7% Cabernet Franc, 2% Petit Verdot. What a fantastic blend, Bordeaux with its tail up! Vigour and verve...

2019

Hawke’s BayNew Zealand

Craggy RangeGimblett Gravels

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Pasqua, Cascina San Vincenzo, Amarone della Valpolicella, Valpantena, Veneto, Italy, 2017

My wines
Locked score

A blend of organically grown 60% Corvina, 30% Corvinone and 10% Rondinella, this is very lively, bright and silky as diamond-polished cherry. At nearly 1000ft...

2017

VenetoItaly

PasquaAmarone della Valpolicella

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Klein Constantia, Vin de Constance, Constantia, South Africa, 2019

My wines
Locked score

The 2019 vintage was a little unpredictable, with 26 passes in the vineyard between late February and late April to determine optimal ripeness. Each pass...

2019

ConstantiaSouth Africa

Klein Constantia

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Yalumba, Y Series Viognier, Barossa Valley, South Australia, Australia, 2021

My wines

90

I’m impressed by this wine. I’ve seen it on offer for £7.50 and even at the regular sub ten pound price, it is a belter for the cash from the masters of Viognier Down Under. Hats off to Yalumba for making such a statement with this entry-level Viognier. It’s got all the peach-skin, honeysuckle fragrance required and much more. Silkiness gives it a real sense of harking back to summer days and in the teeth of winter it’s exactly what I want in my glass to sip with a gentle spicy Thai recipe. It’s also fantastic with seasonal roasted veg. From a warm summer vintage with cool nights, this wild ferment wine has a certain apricot vitality. It’s by no means warming in the sense of feeling like you’ve just embraced a radiator, but as the harbinger of heady summer scents, it’ll give your mind a welcome reminder of fruit in sunbeams.

2021

South AustraliaAustralia

YalumbaBarossa Valley

Cramele Recas, The Wine Atlas Feteasca Regala, Recas, Recas, Banat, Romania

My wines

89

I’m including this Romanian white for several reasons. It is astonishingly good value for a crowd-pleasing party white. Without doubt it’s exotic tropical bloom is a cue for sunnier days to spill around the fountain of memory. And it shows the potential for Romania with local grapes like Royal Maiden also known as Feteasca Regala. One to keep in the fridge for when the carol singers swing by – pour in liberal quantities with snacks. And if you’ve any coronation chicken knocking around, this bargain scented white makes a delightful pairing.

RecasRomania

Cramele RecasRecas

Domaine Tariquet, L’Imprevu, Vin de France, Southwest France, France, 2021

My wines

89

A 9.5% wine as a Winter Warmer? Really? Well, yes. Mainly because it is a 9.5% wine and such a fruity turbo-charged zinger. It’s like switching the headlights on full beam through a citrus frost. Lashings of sharply defined flavour here and slips down all too easily, I’m delighted by this lower alcohol find from buyer Marcel Orford Williams, simply because there is nothing else like it in the whole of France. 66% Riesling with 34% Ugni Blanc, the Grassa Brothers at Domaine Tariquet in Gascony deserve high praise here for creating something so deftly impressive and the perfect aperitif to brighten up the dreariest of days. Good value too.

2021

Southwest FranceFrance

Domaine TariquetVin de France

Undurraga, Terroir Hunter (T.H) Carmenère, Peumo, Cachapoal Valley, Chile, 2018

My wines

92

Lovely sweet core goes right through from start to finish. Does what Carmenère does brilliantly well, delivering similar sensibilities to evolving Bordeaux from a warm vintage but amped up in a quintessentially Chilean style. Lots of deep, dark fruit wafting out of the glass. Plenty of tobacco, blackcurrant fruit pastille underneath that, rippling with intense charisma. Gorgeous seamless crackle of pepper through it as well. Really alive. Silky voluptuous fruity palate with an impressive strata which feels somehow energised. A finish that’s very fine indeed with a wonderful spicy flourish. A good price for a great wine, harnessing a low-yielding plot of ungrafted vines planted in 1998 on the western side of the Valle de Cachapoal, this is great work from talented winemaker and prime vineyard hunter Rafael Urrejola.

2018

Cachapoal ValleyChile

UndurragaPeumo

Beronia, Beronia Rioja Reserva, Rioja, Alta, Rioja, Spain, 2017

My wines

91

For consistency as well as value, Beronia’s Rioja Reserva is one of those rare widely available wines that exceeds expectations and delivers more than the goods – it also conjures delight. With a sheen of voluptuous purity, the eighteen months in French and American oak coaxes a plush velveteen cushion for the fruit to retain a focussed core. The usual sweet spices are all evident, and with just a whisker of mellow warmth I’m happy to call this wine a modern classic. Created from vines with more than 40 years of age, winemaker and technical director Matías Calleja’s quest for excellence is one thing, but the dependable quality across his output is also remarkable. Pour this for a midweek treat or for a special occasion dinner – roast lamb is top of the list as a pairing.

2017

RiojaSpain

BeroniaRioja

Domaine de Verquière, Côtes du Rhône Villages, Plan de Dieu, Rhône, France, 2020

My wines

91

Stunning fragrance. The warmth of summer coming through your glass, the scented garden - between lavender and rose and then really ripe strawberries laced with some heady spice. It’s really scented, complex and alluring. Very attractive, rather like the farm setting of this domaine which was brought to life in 1928 by the great-grandfather of current owner Thibaut Chamfort. 45 organic hectares certified since 2014, the result here is plump, voluptuous fruit tied together with a thread of fine grippy tannin. It’s impressive. To showcase the wine’s plushness I’m pairing it with a cottage pie. At this level, alongside a good price for the quality in the glass, this wine really shows, rather than just being burly and big in an obvious manner, seductive scents and fragrance are all part of the charm. And in this case, it’s proving irresistible.

2020

RhôneFrance

Domaine de VerquièreCôtes du Rhône Villages

Dominio Basconcillos, Viña Magna Tempranillo, Ribera del Duero, Castilla y Léon, Spain, 2020

My wines

90

Behold a quintessential winter warmer! Immense ripe fruit, still graced by a little hint of youthful cherry blossom but lots of very ripe strawberry, raspberry and blackberry prevail wafting up from the glass. Wait until you sip it, just an absolute canyon of fruit – and that would be a mega-canyon gargling all the blackberries there are. It’s brilliantly big. Warmth from the alcohol yes, but in a pleasing way along with prune-like intensity. Lavish texture with a bundle of spice on the finish and a twist of acidity to keep your attention hooked. This is a wine that without question needs food – lamb tagine would work with all that pruney opulence. Or if you’re considering a glass of port at the end of an evening maybe just have this instead. Feels like a real indulgence and wow is it a tasty one.

2020

Castilla y LéonSpain

Dominio BasconcillosRibera del Duero

Kanonkop, Kanonkop Kadette Cape Blend, Stellenbosch, South Africa, 2019

My wines

90

Such a slinky, silky and deliciously balanced blend. It’s magnificent with a roast and works superbly with turkey and all the trimmings too thanks to its graceful intensity. The previous three years of drought carried into this vintage with a smaller crop of high quality and the experience and expertise of winemaker Abrie Beeslaar shows in the handling and blending of 44% Pinotage, 25% Cabernet Sauvignon, 29% Merlot and 2% Cabernet Franc. 3-5 days on skins in open fermenters at 28 degrees C with manual punchdown every two hours and 12 months maturation in second and third fill French Nevers oak barrels. What a wonderful wine to find in the supermarket.

2019

StellenboschSouth Africa

Kanonkop

Thymiopoulos Vineyards, Xinomavro, Naoussa, Macedonia, Greece, 2019

My wines

90

The synergy Apostolos Thymiopoulos shares with the Xinomavro grape and Naoussa in Greece is a harmonious triumvirate that seems to gather more fans daily. To find a wine of this quality, widely available and for under £15 is indeed a boon for wine fans. This Xinomavro, from 25 year old grapes (40% from Trilofos village and 60% from high altitude - 500m - Fytia), has a thrilling balance between fruit, acidity and fine firm tannin thanks to the light touch of six months in oak. Very pale in the glass, if you’re a fan of Barbaresco from Piedmont or Pinot Noir from Alsace, this falls into that similarly ethereal world of elegance and poise. Evocative of rosehip and sundried tomato with cranberry bite and pomegranate depth, there’s an allspice intrigue to this captivating wine. Picture a cherry-coloured flare trailing over a bright winter sky and you’re on the way to this wine’s vibrancy. It’s delicious to decant with roast lamb but serve it with any tomato-based sauce dishes from aubergines to pasta, fish to ratatouille and delight in this brilliant Greek grape.

2019

MacedoniaGreece

Thymiopoulos VineyardsNaoussa

Aldi, Specially Selected Australian Shiraz, South Australia, Australia, 2020

My wines

89

My one word review of this wine is “power”. All the usual Aussie Shiraz descriptors are here with spice and black fruit leading the charge, but what sets this wine apart is its long-lasting satisfying tarry depth. For £5.99 it’s never going to be the world’s finest wine, but bottom line, this wine is better than it needs to be for this price. So if you’re after a bargain for winter parties, simple casseroles, beefy dishes, TV dinners, this is the bottle. It’s also a fab all-rounder to have on standby for festive guests dropping by without worrying too much about how much you’re pouring – as long as you’ve got a few extra bottles on standby!

2020

South AustraliaAustralia

Aldi

Aldi, Specially Selected Valpolicalla Ripasso Superiore, Valpolicella, Ripasso Superiore, Veneto, Italy, 2019

My wines

89

Aldi have done a great job here bringing maximum presence for a great price. Boosted in structure from the Ripasso technique, this is a wine with plenty of spicy intensity – think cloves and plenty of sweet cherry with almond-like flourish. There’s a bit of scent here too, just a hint of rose in bloom and it’s great value for a red with welly without being over the top on the booze. If it’s informal burgers (gorgonzola topping for me), or better yet a cheeseboard this is the bargain bottle for the job. Blended from 75% Corvina 20% Corvinone and 5% Rondinella, keep this congenially priced classic on standby to deploy with the next frosty blast.

2019

VenetoItaly

AldiValpolicella

Château Belle Coline, Blaye Côtes de Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France, 2015

My wines
Locked score

Smooth and direct, good persistence of flavour here, I like the styling, it's just the right side of austere and high toned, giving some pleasurable...

2015

BordeauxFrance

Château Belle ColineBlaye Côtes de Bordeaux

Decanter Premium logo

Join Decanter Premium to unlock all our wines tastings and notes

Join Now

Delicato Family Vineyard, 3 Finger Jack Old Vine Zinfandel, Lodi, California, USA, 2019

My wines

89

Harvested principally from the east of Lodi on stony low vigour soil producing concentrated fruit, this winery is certified under the California Sustainable Winegrowing Alliance. With blueberry boldness and power rippling through the wine, winemaker Alicia Ysais chose to ferment at cooler temperatures to preserve fruity vim and aged this Zinfandel in both French and American oak to season. There is a certain jammy appeal here that works very well with charry flavours in dishes such as smoked or roasted meats - bangers and mash is a slam dunk for the full hearty effect.

2019

CaliforniaUSA

Delicato Family VineyardLodi

Piccini, Memoro NV Rosso di’Italia, Tuscany, Italy

My wines

89

A warming high street red with instant appeal thanks to the silky richness of partially dried grapes. If you’re a fan of Italian Amarone or Ripasso and looking for an affordable kitchen table alternative, this could be right up your street. Founded in 1882 based in the Chianti Classico region with fourth-generation Mario at the helm, Piccini produces 16 million bottles annually and the company owns seven estates across Italy. This non-vintage blend is cleverly constructed to deliver affordable grandeur and while it appears a touch pale in the glass, don’t be discouraged. This red has plenty of sweet fruitcake aromas and is gorgeously silky to sip with dried cherries and cranberries, a hint of sultana and a pleasing bite to the finish that falls somewhere between a sundried tomato and a cherry skin. Thanks to its lean intensity it’s great to pair with bold game dishes from wild boar to venison, also fab with a cheeseboard.

TuscanyItaly

Piccini

Symington Family Estates, Altano Organic Douro, Douro, Douro Valley, Portugal, 2020

My wines

89

With five generations of Symington family know-how in its wake, this organic Douro red blended from 35% Touriga Franca, 25% Touriga Nacional, 20% Alicante Bouschet feels like a bright expression of the Douro’s capacity for intensity and elegance. Don’t for a second think you’re going to get “Port-lite” here, this is a uniquely crafted red blend in its own right. Attractive purple in the glass fading to vibrant crimson it’s very pleasant from off the bat with cherry and mulling spice and a tint of orange peel to entice on the nose. Cherry skin tang, spice on the finish, a warming crackle of white pepper it’s long and fine and will appeal to lovers of fine Italian wines with trademark lively acidity. Try Altano with Spaghetti Bolognese for an offbeat pairing that works a charm.

2020

Douro ValleyPortugal

Symington Family EstatesDouro

Lustau, The Best Pedro Ximenez, Jerez, Spain

My wines

90

Wonderfully intense and sweet, a sticky dried fig the size of a planet blitzed into a thimble’s worth of juice feels about the right ratio to describe the intensity of this luxurious sherry. Smashing to pair with mince pies, fruitcake or even chocolate brownies and just lovely chilled on its own served in small glasses, it cannot fail through the sheer sugar rush alone, to elevate a sense of warming glow through to your core. Made by Lustau, it’s a sensational wine to find on the high street and the price is stupendous for what’s on offer.

JerezSpain

Lustau