From the archive: Vosne-Romanée 2010 – panel tasting results

A great vintage and many of these 2010 wines are now in their drinking windows, so we have dived into our archive to bring you the full panel tasting report from 2012 - online for the first time and including all the tasting notes & scores.

Originally published in the December 2012 issue of Decanter magazine and now available online and in full, exclusively for Premium subscribers.

• 67 wines tasted, with four rated Outstanding

• ‘A golden age’ for Burgundy, concluded our panel of Stephen Brook, Anthony Hanson MW and Jasper Morris MW

Summary

Reduction was the only downside to a great vintage characterised by outstanding premiers crus and a handful of village wines that came close to them in quality, says Stephen Brook…

Although there were occasional disagreements between the judges, the tasting as a whole was remarkably consistent in terms of scoring.

The gap between village and premier cru wines was considerable, as one would expect. Most of the disappointing wines were in the former category, although there was also a handful of village wines that came close to premier cru in quality.

Quick link See all 65 wines scored in this panel tasting

There were some good and mostly consistent scores across several appellations from certain producers, such as Hudelot-Noellat, Lamarche and Jérôme Chezeaux.

Overall, the négociants did not shine, though there were occasional good wines. The main, and unexpected, exception was Louis Latour, whose Chaumes premier cru as well as the top-scoring Petits Monts showed well.

It was good to see the former Domaine Engel, now Domaine d‘Eugénie and the property of Francois Pinault of Château Latour, participating in this tasting, because the wines are rarely seen. The village wine was rather disappointing but the Brûlées was first-rate.

Scroll down to see the top Vosne-Romanée 2010 wines from this panel tasting

The panel was shocked to find two wines so severely reduced that they were not only unpleasant to sniff but almost impossible to taste. A second bottle was equally reduced.

A high level of reduction can sometimes vanish with bottle age, but the panel could not be confident this would happen, so the wines were not scored.

The panel was dismayed that both wines were from Domaine Leroy, one of Burgundy’s top estates, which releases its bottles at eye-watering prices.

I have encountered reduction before at Leroy, such as when tasting the 2008s from cask, but that is not an uncommon problem during barrel ageing and one that is usually not difficult to rectify. To find it spoiling a young bottled wine is far more disturbing.

Despite some disappointment, the overall quality of the premiers crus was outstanding.

The panel was sometimes tempted to give a wine a slight push to place it in the ‘Outstanding’ category – Anne Gros’s Les Barreaux was a case in point – but did not force the issue. Instead, we allowed a wine to bask in its effortlessly high ‘Highly Recommended’ status.

The panel was unanimous in its enthusiasm for the vintage.

Perhaps 2009 may prove the greater in a couple of decades – this was certainly the view of one judge – but at present they seem to be level-pegging, although this is probably only the case at top estates.

The scores

67 wines tasted

Outstanding 4

Highly Recommended 18

Recommended 40

Fair 3

Poor 0

Faulty 2

See all 65 wines scored in this panel tasting

The results

Following the exalted 2009 Burgundy vintage, no one really expected the 2010 releases to fare as well. But our panel found plenty of high-quality village wines and premiers crus, reports Mark O’Halleron…

The inclement weather was expected to make its mark on the 2010 vintage, yet our tasters found plenty to please them. But as Stephen Brook noted, it wouldn’t have been without careful attention at the sorting table.

‘The vintage is a bit of a mystery to me – most of the growing conditions seemed to be so awful, and yet it turned out so well at the end,’ he said. ‘Or should I say, it turned out well for the people who had the resources to sort a lot and get rid of any grapes that were not in perfect condition. There was no evidence of rot or grubbiness in these wines, which indicates they had been properly sorted and selected.’

As to the hallmarks of the vintage, Anthony Hanson MW explained: ‘The vintage has a balancing acidity, which gives it a welcome freshness. In 2009, the wines were splendid and rich but powerful and high in alcohol. These are more classic and may turn out to be finely balanced wines.

‘They remind me of the 1996s, which were not made by the quality of the summer, but by the spring and the September. In 2010, flowering problems led to low yields, resulting in small berries and fruit concentration. Then the autumn weather repaired the problems of the mid-summer. This is a classic year.’

Jasper Morris MW was similarly optimistic: ‘It’s a really super vintage. It reminds me of 2002; it has the same purity, freshness, crispness and finish, and those wines have gone on to get better and better.’

The premiers crus received the highest scores, but Morris said the village-level wines should not be dismissed: ‘There’s a significant difference in price between them, so there’s a proper place for both. If I was to choose six I wanted to buy, then it would be split between the two. There were a couple of excellent, single-vineyard village wines.’

Hanson and Brook concurred, with Brook being ‘surprised’ by the quality of the village wines.

Brook also noted an ‘obvious step up in quality’ with the premier crus. ‘I really liked Beaux Monts; the wines were tight and lean,’ he said.

Hanson, who similarly ‘loved’ this vineyard, also found two ‘really exciting’ wines in Malconsorts, though Suchots was graded as slightly disappointing.

‘Suchots is the biggest and it’s a hard vineyard to get one’s head around,’ explained Morris. ‘It probably doesn’t show enormously well in competitive tastings as it doesn’t have the flair, flamboyance and vibrancy of either Malconsorts, or one or two of the best hillside vineyards. I suspect that in terms of drinking at home, the Suchots might show better. They will gently, gracefully age over a long time but they’re never going to do what Malconsorts does.’

As for cellaring potential, the general verdict was that this was a medium-term vintage. ‘Fifteen to 20 years for the best,’ according to Brook, and Morris agreed: ‘I would be looking to start drinking the premier crus around 2020, and keep going for a while after that, but I wouldn’t expect to have many examples in my cellar after they’re more than 20 years old.’

Brook added: ‘This tasting underlines how much Burgundy has improved in terms of consistency; we found so few poor wines.’ And Hanson agreed: ‘Ten or 15 years ago there would have been much more variation in quality. This shows and there is a far greater, and more regular, production of well-balanced wines, at both premier cru and village levels.’

Our tasters each pick their top 3 wines from the tasting:

Stephen Brook

Brook has been a contributing editor to Decanter since 1996 and has won a clutch of awards for his writing on wine. The author of almost 40 books, his works include The Complete Bordeaux, now the definitive study of the region and in its third edition, and The Wines of California, which has won three awards. Brook is also regional chair for Piedmont at the Decanter World Wine Awards.

‘This was as satisfying a tasting of fine Burgundies from a single village as any that I can recall. With few exceptions, the quality ranged from very good to magnificent. In the past it was prudent to pay the premium for a premier cru if one wanted a Vosne of true quality, but this tasting also confirmed the high quality of many village wines, especially from local growers.

‘It also confirmed the excellence of the 2010 vintage. The difficult growing season meant tasters approached wines from this year with some scepticism when they appeared on the market at the start of 2012. Yet even then, the classicism of the vintage was impressive; today that impression has been reinforced.

‘Until recently it was self-evident that the riper, more opulent 2009 vintage would continue to outflank the less voluptuous 2010s, but that view will need to be revisited over the next few years.

‘The tasting also confirmed the wisdom of the Burgundy hierarchy of vineyards. Not all premiers crus are considered equal, and those regarded as being among the best (and thus rivaling the lesser grands crus, such as Echezeaux) were often among the most admired wines here.

‘Naturally, the skill and experience of the individual producer counted for a great deal, as always in Burgundy.’

Anne Gros, Les Barreaux, Vosne-Romanée 2010

‘Anne Gros is fortunate enough to have some magnificent sites in Vosne, so this is a lesser star in her galaxy. But it was probably the best of a strong range of village Vosnes, with gorgeous aromas, super-ripe flavours, but plenty of vigour and acidity too.’ 93/100 Drink 2013–2025

Domaine François Lamarche, 1er Cru Malconsorts 2010

‘After a sluggish patch, this potentially great estate was taken over by cousins Nicole and Natalie Lamarche in 2006, and quality has soared. This was brilliant in January, and still is, with velvety textures and impeccable fruit and structure.’ 95 Drink 2014–2040

Domaine Michel Gros, 1er Cru Clos des Réas 2010

‘Michel Gros has long made excellent wines from this site. The 2009 was superb and this is probably its equal. It exudes ripe red fruits, while the palate has succulence, harmony and length. Should age well.’ 93 Drink 2014–2030

Anthony Hanson MW

Anthony Hanson has worked in wine since he was 19. He became a Master of Wine in 1976, founded UK importer Haynes Hanson & Clark in 1978 and wrote the book Burgundy in 1982. He joined auction house Christie’s in 2000 and has been instrumental in organising the Hospices de Beaune auction, the world’s oldest charity wine sale.

‘My high expectations were not dented by this fine array. Many 2010 red Burgundies have classic proportions, combining luscious fruit with fine acidity and tannins.

‘This is explained by the extended flowering in the vineyards, which produced many small Pinot berries with thick skins (while reducing the size of the crop). Fine weather in June, July and the crucial vintage period resulted in fresh, well-ripened grapes being picked. Careful sorting allowed only the best grapes and bunches to go into the vats.

‘Among village Vosne-Romanées, there were many well-balanced, early drinking examples, then a noticeable increase in quality, richness and concentration was seen from some named vineyards at this basic appellation level.

‘We then tasted 29 different premiers crus, from eight sites. There were several examples from both Malconsorts and Beaumonts which generally showed well – more consistently than the range of Suchots. Among smaller plots, Les Brûlées, La Croix Rameau, Petits Monts and Chaume each fielded at least one splendid example.

‘The 2010 wines are less opulent than their more famous immediate predecessor, but they have greater freshness and reflect considerable variety from site to site.’

Anne Gros, Les Barreaux, Vosne-Romanée 2010

‘Grapes from this site need a fine autumn to ripen fully, as the hillside curls towards the north. This has a beautiful, purple-garnet colour, showing black and red fruit character on the nose, then substantial fruit density, with lovely, fresh length.’ 93 Drink 2013–2025

Domaine François Lamarche, 1er Cru Les Suchots 2010

‘The domaine has two Suchots plots, one well-placed and one in the depression, where the land dips. The grapes are assembled here, giving a stand-out Suchots cuvée. Balanced, fruity, soft and long. 93 Drink 2013–2030

Domaine Jacques Cacheux, 1er Cru La Croix Rameau 2010

‘This comes from a rarely seen, tiny vineyard which lies between the village and grand cru Romanée-St-Vivant. Deep in colour, fragrantly spicy, richly structured, it has intense fruit and a succulent, fresh aftertaste. 95 Drink 2013–2035

Jasper Morris MW

Jasper Morris MW has made a reputation as one of the world’s leading authorities on Burgundy – originally through his importing company Morris & Verdin, subsequently through his work as Burgundy director at Berry Bros & Rudd, and especially through his book Inside Burgundy, winner of the André Simon award for the best wine book of the year in 2010. Morris is the Regional Chair for Burgundy (excluding Beaujolais) at the Decanter World Wine Awards.

Anne Gros, Les Barreaux, Vosne-Romanée 2010

‘This stood head and shoulders above all others in the village section – and had there been no premiers crus it would surely have been rated Outstanding. The style of the bouquet is quintessentially Vosne-Romanée, touching on the ethereal, and the fruit on the palate presented itself in seamless fashion. Beautifully done.’ 95 Drink 2013–2025

Louis Latour, 1er Cru Les Petits Monts 2010

‘Congratulations to Louis Latour for this beautiful wine, just a notch ahead of its other premier cru, Les Chaumes. Does this mark an evolution in style? Certainly the Petits Monts had a thrilling purity and elegance to it.’ 95 Drink 2013–2035

Domaine Jacques Cacheux, 1er Cru La Croix Rameau 2010

Few people have come across this tiny premier cru, an enclave within Romanée-St-Vivant, but they might want to know about this wine, which is not far short of grand cru quality itself. Not only is it an immensely attractive wine, but it has a touch of nobility to it as well.’ 95 Drink 2013–2035

About Vosne-Romanée

Vosne-Romanée may be a small area, but its splendid sites consistently yield some of Burgundy’s best wines, including grands and premiers crus, explains Stephen Brook…

Some individual vineyards in Burgundy, such as Le Musigny and Clos de Bèze, can match those of Vosne-Romanée for excellence and renown, but no other village can lay claim to such a roster of fabulous sites as Vosne.

There are the magnificent monopoly grands crus – Romanée-Conti, La Tâche, La Romanée – and other grands crus, such as Romanée-St-Vivant and Richebourg, that scarcely lag behind in quality, but also a handful of premiers crus that often rival the top growths in splendour.

So many great sites come at a cost – the top wines of Vosne, whatever their official status, are invariably expensive. Owned by some of the most perfect estates in Burgundy – Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, Sylvain Cathiard, the Gros family, Méo-Camuzet, Liger-Belair and many others – their wines rarely fail to deliver, not just in exquisite fruit and beguiling complexity, but in longevity too. We have every reason to expect the highest quality from these wines: in a fine year, Vosne is as good as it gets.

Vosne-Romanée in 2010

The 2010 vintage was certainly fine, if not perhaps on the same exalted level as 2005 or 2009, although bottle age often yields surprises. The early summer was warm, even hot at times, but damp spells led to mildew and rot. A wet August slowed the ripening. September was warmer but stormy.

Vineyards with lower yields and thus thicker skins resisted the rot reasonably well, but after the harvest began, sorting proved essential. Overall, between one- third and half of the crop was rejected. What remained was healthy and ripe, and growers reported wines that were fresher and showed more purity than in 2009.

Terroir expression was stronger than in 2009, with its hotter and more uniform conditions, and some winemakers, such as Philippe Prost of Bouchard Père et Fils, preferred the classicism of 2010 to the opulence of 2009. But that was probably a minority view.

Outstanding wine

The southern part of Vosne borders Nuits-St-Georges, while the northern vineyards are adjacent to those of Chambolle-Musigny; Vougeot lies tucked into the north-east corner of the village.

Aux Malconsorts is the most important premier cru close to Nuits-St-Georges, yet it can still show amazing finesse; Cros Parantoux and Les Petits Monts lie just above Richebourg, while Beaux Monts, Brulées and Suchots are closer to the centre of the village.

The elevation of Beaux Monts generally results in perfumed wines that appear lighter than some other top premiers, but which age well nonetheless. All these sites are capable of producing truly outstanding wine.

Potential candidates for promotion to grand cru – but don’t hold your breath – would include Malconsorts, Suchots and Cros Parantoux. Clearly the skill of the winemakers plays an important role, too.

What should one expect from a fine Vosne-Romanée? For a start, density of flavour, obtained from moderate yields of relatively old vines. But also a profound elegance – not in the more ‘feminine’ sense of many a Volnay or Chambolle, but allied to intensity and length of flavour, as well as a robustness that never descends into coarseness.

Top Vosne-Romanée 2010 from this panel tasting:

You might also like:

From the archive: Chambolle-Musigny 2014 panel tasting results

Best white Burgundy: Top-rated & top value

Comparing Cos d’Estournel wines: 2000 to 2016