Michaela Morris: My top wines of 2023
I can truly say, that in 2023, my fine wine cup overflowed – particularly with exquisitely aged examples. Michaela shares her top 10 standout bottles from the past year.
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
You are now subscribed
Your newsletter sign-up was successful
The year began auspiciously with a Decanter panel tasting evaluating the cellaring potential of Chianti Classico. At 25 years old, San Giusto a Rentennano’s 1998 Riserva was a resounding validation. Soon after, at the denomination’s annual-release tasting, Podere Il Palazzino’s 2016 Grosso Sanese lent positive reinforcement to the Gran Selezione category.
Scroll down to see tasting notes and scores for Michaela Morris’ top 10 wines of 2023
Onwards to a zone more commonly fêted for the longevity of its wines, Montalcino’s producers were generous in sharing from their libraries. Topping the list, Biondi-Santi uncorked a Riserva from the much-lauded 1988 vintage – and did it ever live up to its reputation!
Of Brunello di Montalcino’s current releases, I was reminded yet again that even challenging vintages yield cellar-worthy specimens. Sesti’s Phenomena Riserva wondrously transcended the excruciatingly dry, hot conditions of 2017 while simultaneously expressing the year with ease.
From the variable 2018, San Filippo’s La Lucère captured everything that is positive about the vintage – buoyancy and finesse of structure – and is the best that I have tasted from this estate.
Piedmont was not to be outdone by Tuscany. Among multiple excursions there, I led Decanter’s first ever wine tour in Italy, which included an unforgettable dinner at the three-star Michelin Piazza Duomo.
I also spent time catching up with a cross-section of producers. After tasting the excellent 2019 Barolos at Aldo Conterno, Alessandro Conterno opened a bottle of 2006 Granbussia Riserva. Only nine years old when it was made, he had no specific memory of the year. He chose it simply because the wine reminded him of home. Indeed, it was so hauntingly evocative of a region that has almost become a second home for me.
In Piedmont’s cool alpine corner of Carema, Monte Maletto’s 2019 Sole e Roccia reiterated Nebbiolo’s stunning potential further afield.
Get our daily fine wine reviews, latest wine ratings, news and travel guides delivered straight to your inbox.
During the madness of Vinitaly in April, I made sure to stop for a quick sip of Tiberio’s Fonte Canale Trebbiano d’Abruzzo. While the newly released 2020 could be the best vintage of this single-vineyard wine yet, I took more pleasure in a leisurely glass of the 2019 at a gathering with Vancouver’s top somms. Still an infant, it is emblematic of Italy’s ageworthy whites.
Beyond Italy, I was thrilled to travel to Austria for the first time ever. The impeccably organized ÖTW – or Traditional Wine Estates’ Single Vineyard Summit – allowed me the opportunity to taste through 500 of the country’s leading wines. I was particularly impressed with those from Kamptal, where Jurtschitsch was a new discovery for me. Among the estate’s lovely range, I singled out the 2021 Ried Heiligenstein Alte Reben Riesling.
Undoubtedly, the most epic tasting of the year was a fundraising dinner featuring over 40 wines from Bordeaux’s legendary 1982 vintage. Decanter’s Bordeaux Editor, Georgie Hindle made the trek to my hometown of Vancouver to cover the event. For my palate, the top wine was a toss-up between Latour and Lafite. While the former, unbelievably, still seemed to be asking for more time, the latter seduced with immediate gratification – if you can call it that after four decades.
It is impossible to imagine a tasting to top this. But who knows what 2024 holds…
Michaela’s top wines of 2023
Wines are listed white then red in score order
Related articles
- Festive treats: The best wines to seek out in December 2023
- Brunello di Montalcino 2018: full report plus top-scoring wines
- Chianti Classico Annata: New releases in 2023
Jurtschitsch, Ried Heiligenstein Alte Reben Riesling, Kamptal, Niederösterreich, Austria, 2021

What a smouldering siren! An old-vine selection from the Heiligenstein vineyard, where the south- to southwest-facing slopes sit on Permian bedrock (weathered desert sandstone with volcanic conglomerates). The nose quietly reveals nuances of wet stone and lemon curd, with a subtle suggestion of creamy lees. The palate follows through with an embryonic mix of citrus, stone fruit and crushed rocks tightly woven in the core. Lightweight but with sneaky concentration, this is sinewy, taut and electrifying. The racy green apple spine leads to a zesty lemon zip on the finish. Ageing is in 10-hectolitre oak foudres.
2021
NiederösterreichAustria
JurtschitschKamptal
Tiberio, Fonte Canale, Trebbiano d’Abruzzo, Abruzzo, Italy, 2019

A beguiling nose slowly reveals camomile and lemon balm underscored by earthier hints of bay leaf and hazelnut shells. Vertically fashioned, the palate is über-focused and bracing yet well-padded with succulent apricot. Chalky and saline accents lend intrigue, drawing out the tangy, tantalising finish. Tiberio’s Fonte Canale vineyard is a mere hectare or so, and the 90-plus-year-old, double pergola-trained vines are painfully low yielding, which makes for tiny quantities. By no means a substitute, the excellent value estate Trebbiano d’Abruzzo is more readily available and I often pour it as my house white.
2019
AbruzzoItaly
TiberioTrebbiano d’Abruzzo
Château Lafite Rothschild, Pauillac, 1er Cru Classé, Bordeaux, France, 1982

A demure yet confident beauty, the 1982 Lafite is in its prime and will delight anyone privy to an audience. Scents of tobacco, sandalwood and spice box waft with increasing intensity as this sits in the glass, then it floats across the palate leaving a persistent trail of stony minerals: flint and graphite along with preserved cherries are laced with sweet, smoky incense, and radiant acidity gives a perception of weightlessness while shedding light on the wine’s depths. So effortlessly and elegantly framed, and as exquisitely perfect as this is now, there is nothing to suggest it will fade any time soon.
1982
BordeauxFrance
Château Lafite RothschildPauillac
Aldo Conterno, Granbussia Riserva, Barolo Bussia, Monforte d’Alba, Piedmont, Italy, 2006

Produced since 1974 but only in select years, Granbussia takes the Romirasco vineyard as its backbone and is co-fermented with equal portions (15% each) of Cicala and Colonnello – all vineyards within the Bussia MGA. Poignantly redolent of the Langhe in autumn, this opens with heady scents of the truffle hunt – not just the fungi itself but the moist earth it was extracted from and the oak and hazelnut trees among which it grows. There are also balsamic sage hints, and a suggestion of rust and iron on the palate. It is mighty and formidable with an unrelenting grip, yet those tannins are regal, sculpting dense layers of dark, brooding fruit. Mouth-cleansing acidity makes this soar, but If you do drink now, uncork it well ahead of time and give it a long, long time to unfurl in the glass.
2006
PiedmontItaly
Aldo ConternoBarolo Bussia
Biondi-Santi, Riserva La Storica, Brunello di Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy, 1988

<p>The Riserva release that marks the centenary (1888-1988) of Biondi-Santi was appropriately born of an exceptional growing season: a very rainy spring; warm, dry summer; and cool, dry harvest. Viticulture and winemaking director Federico Radi – who was still in short trousers when this was made – was full of superlatives for this wine, whose remarkable youthfulness, even at 37 years old, will see it mature for another decade with grace. Cool, flinty acidity, melting tannins and amazing length and drinkability in its bergamot, redcurrant, tobacco and fresh balsamic flavours. Aged in Slavonian oak casks for 36 months. <strong>RADI'S RECAP:</strong> Pure elegance.</p>
1988
TuscanyItaly
Biondi-SantiBrunello di Montalcino
San Giusto a Rentennano, Chianti Classico, Riserva, Tuscany, Italy, 1998

A former medieval Cistercian convent, San Giusto a Rentennano has been in the Martini di Cigala family since 1914. Today it is run by siblings Elisabetta, Francesco and Luca, with the guidance of consultant Attilio Pagli since 1999. The 31ha of vineyards sit at an average of 270m in the warm and luminous southern reaches of Gaiole. The estate has been producing a Riserva since 1975 and continues to opt out of the Gran Selezione category. Michaela Morris: Very meaty and minty, with some tobacco notes, too, and dry, dusty tannins. Wears its heart on its sleeve. Drink now. Sara Bachiorri: Balsamic aromas with porcini, musk and wet bark. A fully evolved palate of coffee and dried red berries, with a silky texture and a long finish. Michelle Cherutti-Kowal MW: Dried cherries, plums and mushrooms on the nose, with hints of iodine and earth. Smooth tannins and good persistence.
1998
TuscanyItaly
San Giusto a RentennanoChianti Classico
San Filippo, La Lucère, Brunello di Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy, 2018

Planted in 1997, La Lucère is encircled by forest on three sides. The breezy, east-facing site is relatively cool and always the estate’s last to be harvested. Aged in lightly toasted barriques and tonneaux, 20% new, the 2018 is the most elegantly sculpted and effortlessly balanced wine I have tasted from the estate. It opens with attractive scents of cinnamon, violet and rosemary, and boasts impressive concentration of woodland berry flavours but isn’t heavy. Integrated acidity provides proper support, and the tannins are long and fine, giving texture and shape. The best is still yet to come.
2018
TuscanyItaly
San FilippoBrunello di Montalcino
Podere Il Palazzino, Grosso Sanese, Chianti Classico, Gran Selezione, Tuscany, Italy, 2016

Visiting Il Palazzino’s rustic, cluttered tasting room is like walking back in time. As for the wines, they are non-conformist and a bit edgy, but full of soul – above all, the Grosso Sanese bottling. This 100% Sangiovese began life as a Vino da Tavola in the 1980s before joining the ranks of the DOCG in 1996, and finally became a Gran Selezione with the 2015 vintage. The current release, 2016, features a bouquet of leather, incense, mint tea and wild game; decidedly tertiary but by no means tired. The palate is equally savoury and earthy, as forest undergrowth and bitter roots permeate dark black currants. Fully charged with waves of firm tannins, this demands a rare steak.
2016
TuscanyItaly
Podere Il PalazzinoChianti Classico
Sesti, Phenomena Riserva, Brunello di Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy, 2017

Aromatically and texturally extraordinary, Phenomena is one of the vintage’s great triumphs. Gorgeous scents of pressed rose, orange peel and Mediterranean shrub are penetrating and inviting. Round and full, the palate exhibits the warmth of the year without violating its carefully drawn boundaries. Powdery tannins caress the palate, wrapping around spice-laced, fleshy persimmon. As tempting as it is now, there is structure and stuffing for ageing. Phenomena's 2017 label commemorates the colourful Geminid meteor shower of December 2017.
2017
TuscanyItaly
SestiBrunello di Montalcino
Monte Maletto, Sole e Roccia, Carema, Piedmont, Italy, 2019

‘Sun and stone’ is Nebbiolo blended with 5% of the local Ner d’Ala variety, from approximately half a hectare of vines on Carema’s terraced slopes. It sees about 30% stem inclusion, a long maceration of 40 days and ageing in used barriques. Reverberating with its mountain origins, it exudes alpine bitters, green herbs and liquorice root. The palate seems delicate, almost fleeting at first, then builds with fine-boned tannins, stony minerals and penetrating flavours of redcurrant and blood orange. As bracing as the cold mountain air.
2019
PiedmontItaly
Monte MalettoCarema
